Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

The Problem with Pirates (too easy)
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> General Hints and strategies Goto page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Yellowbeard
Seaman
Posts: 201


7885 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat May 21, 2005 1:03 pm    Post subject: The Problem with Pirates (too easy) Reply with quote

This stems from a thread on the minigames in Pirates, but I thought these comments might deserve their own thread (call me conceited). I was discussing the problem that the game focuses too much on fencing, which as-it-is now is waaay too easy and creates a lot of unrealistic war canoe jockeys... this is how Pirates would be IN MY WORLD:

**************************************

The main problem with war canoes winning more battles then SotL goes right back to the horrid fencing problems (ie: waaaaaay too easy).

I'm not saying Fencing should be impossible to win or only happen 25% of the time (forcing a reload), I'm saying fencing battles SHOULD MAKE SENSE.

Here's what I'm saying... crew size should be a lot more important in a fencing battle then it currently is... right now if you're on a war canoe with 30 men, charging a 250 manned SotL to board, fence and win is a no-brainer because you can't lose.

If I was all omnipotant and could snap my finger and change Pirates, Anybody who boarded a 250-manned SotL with a crew of 30-men would have about a 1-in-100 shot of winning the battle... sorry, but you're an idiot if you board in this situation. Now if you boarded with a much larger crew, your odds would improve... and say if you boarded with an equal sized crew, you'd stand a very strong chance of winning the battle (but it's still not automatic... there should be SOME risk in every boarding action).

Bottom line, making EVERY boarding action at least SOMEWHAT risky would force out a lot of these canoe jockeys and put more emphasis on ship-to-ship battles and trying to force a striking of the colors (the only risk-free way of winning a battle).

In the same breath, the smaller the ship, the greater the risk should be applied... I'm sorry, but in my mind, a "war canoe" made by indians shouldn't be worth ANYBODY's time... nobody should even remotely consider using an indian war canoe to sail the high seas and battle with frigates... I would propose the smaller the ship, the greater the chance of sinking in battle... ie: a flimsy war canoe might sink with a single cannon ball hit (maybe two), and could never carry a SINGLE cannon (how many indian war canoes every carried cannons?). If your boat could sink with a single hit, and you couldn't carry any cannons, and boarding a large enemy ship with 30 men was suicide, how many war canoe jockeys would we have then?

Pinnaces and Mail Runners could carry a few guns (not many) and would also be fairly easy to sink. Once again, with the fixes to fencing rules, ships of this size would probably not be very popular... once you start getting to sloops and above things start balancing out again, but as I mentioned, the changes in fencing rules should put a premium on large crews and bigger ships, which is historically more logical. This would also slow the progression rate of getting bigger ships. As it stands now, you can start the game in a sloop, and within minutes be sailing a Frigate (probably because of fencing)... that's just not right. With making smaller ships more easily destroyed by gunfire and making crew sizes count more in fencing duals, you could make this game a lot more interesting, more challenging and make a lot more sense.

I'm not saying this to force people to have to reload multiple times... you would only be doing that if you were dumb enough to take on a SotL in a war canoe. Either that, or you get greedy and try to take on a Large Frigate with a Sloop... at least then, you might stand a remote chance of winning if your skills were up to snuff, but it would no longer be an automatic thing... with the changes I suggest, your better course of action as a Sloop pirate would be to capture something easier (like a Brig) and then use the Brig to capture the Frigate... this would force a more natural flow of progression in the game and take the war canoe jockeys out of business (which frankly makes no sense at all).

Of course, my main problem is that I am not omnipotent and do not have mastery over all time space and dimensions. Woe is me... I'm stuck with War Canoes taking on SotL and winning!
Question

FINAL NOTE:
In my perfect world of Pirates.. a Frigate (or bigger) would be feared by anyone not sailing something equal (or at least close) in size... yeah, maybe you'd take on a frigate if you had your own frigate, or at least a brig, but if you were in a sloop or smaller, you'd either run or you'd be very confident of your skills... that's the way it would be in real life and that's the way it should be in this game... once I figured out how easy this game is, Frigates don't scare me (or anyone I would imagine)... instead folks in war canoes make a bee-line for these ships... that's just wrong!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
rupertlittlebear
Helmsman
Posts: 4434


10417 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Sat May 21, 2005 4:04 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Have you told Firaxis lately?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Kensai
Seaman
Posts: 181


1462 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Sat May 21, 2005 5:21 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

There isn´t any logic in this game, love it or hate it.
The creators didn´t tried to make a "sailing simulator", and if it was the original idea, they were wrong in the results.

Any one of you knows why the Viking era of ships came to an end?
I´m sure that all of you knows that vikings LOVED to board enemy ships and slaughter everyone, but they started to loose, when ships were maded with higger decks, like Galleons, for example.
They needed to escalate for a fight, and then they were easily killed, from upside of the ship.

So, that a war Canoe can defeat a SOTL, with 30 guys against 200, going up, it´s impossible, but as Rupert said one times, "nobody dies in this game".

Realism isn´t a strong point of this game.
If War canoes were the answer in the real battlefield, the british fleet were maded with those tiny ships, don´t spending fortunes with those giant SOTLS, Fragates, Brigs, etc.

I enjoy it because it´s funny, that´s all, and the most important thing.
It´s the first game that I play again, and again, and again, don´t know why, but that´s the true for me.

The problem, I think, if someone of us wants a good realistic simulator, the game will need to be re-programed ALL again from the very beginning.

Forget it, I don´t think will exist a Pirates 3 "The apologises from Sid for all this historic, bugs and common sense mistakes".

Keep sailing Sailor
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Westley_Roberts
Iron Guts
Posts: 913



10375 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat May 21, 2005 6:00 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

You know, I really didn't think I was going to get on my soapbox for this one, but I think I will today...

I can completely understand everyones feelings with this game being way too easy..

I remember fondly my days spent playing the original on my C-64 / C-128, Amiga Machines. It was fun, challenging, and even entertaining. This version, even if it reminds me of the fun I had, seems WAY TOO EASY ! ! !

I fell in with the Canoe Jockeys, I would have 80 men, and harass everything in my path, no ship was safe. After a successful boarding, sometimes the old crew would volunteer to sail with me. I'd take them along to help man their old boat. Until I sold it, and marooned them in town with no gold for their efforts. Heck, they should be happy I didn't leave them in the water. But Jeesh, I sail right up to anything, even trrop transports, missing all the cannons aimed for me, to sit there and slice the captain a new one. Too EASY..
Then there is the aspect of getting the 126, TOO EASY!! Tick off the Spanish to get all the other promotions, then have an Abbot speak in your corner, and whoosh, all is forgiven, and now I can prey on all of the guys I once defended to gain rank with the Spanish, all the while not losing anything from the other countries.. WASSUP WIT DAT!?!?!?!

I almost never take over a town, too slow for land battles. All the pretty soldiers walking over a hill, and then that lone straggler...UGG...Not worth it.

Then the insipid chaseing after the same guy time after time for info on family?? Come on, if you have all the answers, give them to me all at once...

The only fun I really have is getting to the hideout, making the indians chase my cannon fodder, whilst my Officers do an end run for the gates.
$100,000 bonus for that?? ok, I'll take it but that was way easy!!

OK, I'm done, I've hashed enough on this game for today....Next..... Sailor
_________________

Have an Army Day
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
Cussler
Cutthroat
Posts: 371


2686 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat May 21, 2005 6:19 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I guess the ease of this game came from Atari wanting to make a family-friendly adventure.

You know. According to the storyline, you're not an evil pirate. You're a young man, trying to avenge a terrible crime. Find your family. Get married, etc. No one dies, not even Montalban!

So, I suspect the ease comes from trying to expand the fanbase and fit with the adventure. It's not supposed to be hard or realistic. It's a swashbuckling adventure where your small band of buccaneers can take on almost anything, so that anyone can pick up the game and get right into it.

I'd be kind of peeved if I had to spend the first few years of my adventures trying to upgrade to larger and larger ships, all the while letting Treasure Galleons, Military Payrolls, Raymondo, and Invasion Forces go.

I also wouldn't like having to always go for larger ships and crews, because that ultimately forces me to have to divide the plunder from time to time, losing months of looting and pillaging opportunities.

But this is all just my opinion. Perhaps Firaxis should have made the Swashbuckler level more realistic, and not just a harder version of the regular format. That way everyone would be happy.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Yellowbeard
Seaman
Posts: 201


7885 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat May 21, 2005 6:26 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
if someone of us wants a good realistic simulator

I'm not asking for a simulator... I'm really not asking for much of a change at all... I'd bet if Firaxis really wanted to, this could be a very simple fix (not that I expect it to happen).

The game could remain essentially as it is now... the only differance? If you board a 250-man ship with 30 crew, the odds of you winning the dual is next to nil... if you board with a roughly equal crew... you stand a decent chance of winning but you still take some risk.

War canoes? Can't carry cannons at all, and one or two shots of cannon will sink one. None of this would require a complete rewrite of the game, I'm sure all of it could be done if Firaxis wanted to (but they won't).

Bottom line, you shouldn't be able to terrorize the Spanish Main from Sloops to Ships of the Line in an indian war canoe... that's not asking for a "simulation", that's asking for some common sense!

There's, easy, there's 'accesible to all', then there's "what are you smoking crack" too-easy and unbelievable.

The game is fun... but I still think it would be just as fun, if not MORE fun if there was the slightist whim of believability... is it too much to ask that a war canoe might not be a good match-up against a ship of the line? Come on now... this is just TOOOO EASY.

This reminds me of one of Sid's other games... Civilization I. Remember when a battleship would fire it's 16in guns from the ocean against some bronze-armor, wearing, spearchucking phalanx units, and the battleship would sink with nary a scratch to the phalanx? War Canoes vs SotL remind me of this.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
SubDivi
Powder Monkey
Posts: 30



842 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun May 22, 2005 4:44 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Cussler wrote:
I guess the ease of this game came from Atari wanting to make a family-friendly adventure.

You know. According to the storyline, you're not an evil pirate. You're a young man, trying to avenge a terrible crime. Find your family. Get married, etc. No one dies, not even Montalban!


I know where the tone is set, but they didn't have to dumb-down the gameplay too so the 6 year old could sit down and learn how to play it within a few days. Also there is the option of having the Simulation/Arcade modes as someone earlier mentioned. It shouldn't be THAT hard to make some improvements in the realism area.

I know they've heard the term "Jack of All Trades, Master of None". If you try to please everyone, you're lucky if you please anyone. Humans aren't exactly backwards compatable. XP

Cussler wrote:
I'd be kind of peeved if I had to spend the first few years of my adventures trying to upgrade to larger and larger ships, all the while letting Treasure Galleons, Military Payrolls, Raymondo, and Invasion Forces go.


My last Rogue game, I captured an SOTL with 40 men and a Sloop of War in my SECOND MONTH. I was enthusiastic for 5 minutes untill it dawned on me that.. well.. I didn't really feel I Earned that ship.

-----

At first I thought i'd love this game to death.. but.. I can't really find anything rewarding about my accomplisments in it now. This game is centered around your accomplisments as a Pirate.. so, lets see...

Find all of the Named Pirate Treasures... check! You know.. if they care so much about their booty that they attack you on sight after you loot is.. why did they invest all of that gold on decorating it so well? Even equipped with it's own Neon "X" Light.

Make all of the Named Pirates "Walk the Plank"... check! You know, they really shouldn't hire the local Choir Boys to defend their precious ships.. I would also suggest to them a War Canoe! Forget 40 Guns! I've got 40 Pattle-Powered "Ingin'" on my side!

Become Duke of All Nations.... check! Somehow this just seemed to happen as I plundered any and every juicy ship I wanted... I did get in trouble a few times but I just bribed the abbot with the grace of speaking to him. Damn that guys well connected! Wait.. oh yeah.. heh, I guess God really IS in my corner!

Marry a Beauty... check! Dance with her once after buying a macaroni hat.. give her a Ring I bought from some random guy at the tavern who.. just happens to try and sell everyone one everytime they speack to him... defeated an, obviously very poor 'fiance' who wouldn't spring for a little "bling". Dance with her again.. Rescue her from a guy who apparently has a crush on every girl I take interest in.. I guess on the inside he's just sad because he can't have me.. Then bam! She wan't to get married! Who cares if you're the dire enemy of her nation.. even if you take over her town she'll switch out brains with the next gouverner's daughter! Oh, and you can flirt with whoever you like.. and you don't ever have to see her for the next.. infinity.

Find me Family... check! Saw them for 30 seconds and just dropped them off at the nearest seaport never to see them again.. I guess..

Defeat Montalban - My Arch-Nemisis... check! Dance with a few girls who have a girlfriend over across the Main who just celled them about ole' Monty's arrival.. go over and defeat him about 30 dozen time.. apparently he had himself cloned... go over to his hideout and shower his Ingin' buddies with my boomstick a few times.. then I just poke ole' Monty with me Cutlass a few and he not only gives me 100,000 gold but also his closest servants and offers himself up as a ship steward.. who.. I apparently never interact with. Happy Days!

Find the Lost Cities of Ancients... check! It's really strange that everybody seems to get these map pieces. I wasn't aware the Ancients drew maps depicting where they are.. even in current day terms! If not them.. then why are they "Lost" Cities? I wish I had a map to everything I lost..

----

I agree about the War Canoe. I shouldn't even be able to BOARD a Frigate with a little rowboat, let alone take one down. Also, what the heck happens to the 100 Crew left on the ship I just took over.. I mean.. do they just surrender? Are they really that brainless? Added onto that.. isn't it funny how a Pinnace can have the same deck-size as a Galleon? Quite funny indeed!

----

I like how this game goes about representing "Pirates"; they modeled it after the "silver-screen" pirates.. which I quite like! However.. even SSPirates had to follow the rules of reality every once in a while.

Ofcourse, this also comes from a person who thinks the dancing minigame is one of the most well-done aspects of the game; so don't mind my views.
_________________
Some men bring home the bacon - I choose to bring home the booty.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
rupertlittlebear
Helmsman
Posts: 4434


10417 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Sun May 22, 2005 4:49 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

rupertlittlebear wrote:
Have you told Firaxis lately?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Vulture
Gunner
Posts: 501


606 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Sun May 22, 2005 11:19 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Ok, ok. I read all the stuff on this thread and I kinda see your point on this stuff, but.............................The game was created to HAVE FUN WITH.

Now, Imagine If they made the swordfights very realistic. Imagine how long it would take you to get a large brig. 4 years? 5? And dont forget even if you win the swordfight and some of your crew survived you would spend most of your time licking your wounds, trying to recruit more men, and repairing your ship. You would have to do this after every engagement at the begining of the game. It would truly become frustrating and the games sucsess would be, well, it would not be.

Games have to have ONLY one thing to be great. PLAYABILITY. Not realism. Look back at all the games you have purchased. What made them great. It wasn't the degree of realism, It was the playability. What for Pete's sake was real in Diablo, Warcraft, Morrowwind....etc.

If you take the fencing aspect out of the game, there is no game. You want realism? How many Governors would actually want their daughter to associate with a known pirate. Not too many.

You want realism? Most Pirates careers lasted a few short years, and generally speaking, even fewer ever got that huge haul of gold and jewels.

The bottom line is they made the game fun. If you want to be the scourge of the seas in a war canoe...so be it. I, for one, don't sail war canoes but I do not fault Firaxis for allowing that to occur. It adds to the playability of the game.

If you want tougher fights play at swash. I have swam quite a lot. I have become an expert at doing dives off of poop decks.
_________________

32 brightly polished cannons, a bottle o'rum, ahh..... a pirates life for me!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Yellowbeard
Seaman
Posts: 201


7885 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun May 22, 2005 2:04 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I figured someone would get all defensive, take offense I said something negative about the game, and put a bunch of words into my mouth I never said... vulture, you take the prize on that one.

I didn't suggest changing the game so we couldn't have fun.

I didn't say I wanted fencing removed from the game.

The changes I suggested would not remove PLAYABILITY.

I didn't say I wanted a realistic Pirate sim where everyone gets scurvey and dies at 24.

I've fenced at Swash, it's not that much tougher, the problem with Swash is all the other "lazy AI cheats" like Brigs that move at the speed of light. I don't play games where the programmer was so lazy the only way he could think to make it tougher was to give unfair cheats to the AI the human can't have.

Please don't put words in my mouth... please don't get all defensive because I had constructive criticism... your response sounded like you personally invented the game yourself and I just slapped you in the face.

WHAT I DID SAY...

Don't need to change the game that much... I'M NOT LOOKING FOR A SIMULATOR FOR THE LAST FRICKIN TIME!

I'M NOT ASKING TO REMOVE SWORD FIGHTS FROM THE GAME... I NEVER SAID THAT... I simply asked that 30 men should not be able to kick the snot out of 300 men so easily. Would changing this aspect ruin your game vulture?

Vulture... instead of getting all peeved I poked a few holes in this game... SLOWLY go over what I wrote, READ AND UNDERSTAND what I said without getting all defensive. Take a breath... relax... understand.

1) Make it where 30 men can't beat 300 men easily... note this hardly removes swordfights from the game.

2) Make smaller ships hold less cannons and easier to sink.

That's pretty much all I ask. If you had bothered to have read my post without taking major offense and getting all defensive, you would have realized I wasn't asking for a Pirate sim or to rewrite into a completely differant game... I ask for two tweaks that would make the game both more realistic and more challenging. Nothing more, nothing less.

Next time read what I said and don't put words into my mouth.

The fact is, this game is so easy, as a previous poster mentioned, you can fire a new game up and pretty much have the biggest ship under your control within minutes of playing. Wow... that was fun! What's next for a goal? I suppose if the changes I suggest mean you might actually have to play for an hour before getting the biggest ship, folks are going to whine... so if the changes I suggest are implemented, I suggest that a "GOD MODE" be left in the game so people can use war canoes to capture a SotL two minutes into the game (NOTE: God Mode = game as it currently is now).

I don't dislike the game... it is fun... however it seems to be targeted (by difficulty level) to 6-year olds. The changes I suggest would merely make a fun game have some level of challenge for somebody over the age of 6 without having to deliberetely handicap yourself (Flutes of war) just to find any level of challenge.

Speaking of Flutes of War... as anyone noticed the only way to actually take up that challenge and win, is by boarding and fencing? That might point to an obvious problem with the game (ie: fencing solves all problems because it's so automatic a win).
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun May 22, 2005 3:50 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

We ARE all playing at Swash, aren't we?
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Yellowbeard
Seaman
Posts: 201


7885 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun May 22, 2005 4:17 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Everyone playing at Swash STILL takes over SotL with War Canoes, aren't they? If anything, Swash only encourages canoe jockeys more because of the ridiculous speed advantage of AI controlled large ships on Swash level.

The problem is not with difficulty level, the problem is with the inherant nature of the game to use 30 men to take over 300 ON ANY LEVEL.

I've read countless threads from people playing all levels (Swash included) and people will take less then 30 men vs a fully crewed (200+) large ship, because they feel they can't lose. When people EXPECT to win with such odds, there is a MAJOR problem with the game.

Tell me it isn't so.

This is NOT an issue of difficulty level, this is an issue that fencing IN GENERAL is not even remotely close to being properly modeled on any level. Let's not even get into a discussion on why an AI Fluyt can sail faster then a human controlled Mail Runner on Swash level. That's a differant issue.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
rupertlittlebear
Helmsman
Posts: 4434


10417 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Sun May 22, 2005 4:34 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

rupertlittlebear wrote:
Have you told Firaxis lately?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Vulture
Gunner
Posts: 501


606 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Sun May 22, 2005 4:37 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I wasn't trying to upset you Yellowbeard. Nor was I trying to "put words in your mouth". I apoligize if my point of view was upsetting to you, it was not my intention to cause a mutiny. Have a swig of rum and lets chillout. Smooth Sailing
_________________

32 brightly polished cannons, a bottle o'rum, ahh..... a pirates life for me!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Yellowbeard
Seaman
Posts: 201


7885 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun May 22, 2005 4:47 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Aaargh... I not be upset with ye Vulture... I just think you mistook what I was saying should be done (in me own opinion).

I just wanted to clarify I didn't think the game needed to be thrown out and drastically reprogrammed, but rather a little common sense needed to be injected when it came to sword fights... it's not very common, even in Pirate movies for 30 men to routinely tackle 300 and win every time. Nor do you ever see Pirate movies where they tackle enemy Frigates in an Indian War Canoe... I think the game, as it is now, takes a LOT of liberty with anything remotely close to reality.

It doesn't have to be total farsical fantasy to be fun... you can have SOME realism in the game and it still be fun... all I ask is that the sword fights be a little more tilted toward reality and the war canoe jockey club be a little less enticing to join.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> General Hints and strategies All times are GMT
Goto page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next
Page 1 of 5

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group