Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

What frustrates you about Sid Meier's Pirates!
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Pirates! Chat Goto page 1, 2, 3, 4  Next
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
scandinavian
Powder Monkey
Posts: 24


1618 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Jul 31, 2014 4:39 pm    Post subject: What frustrates you about Sid Meier's Pirates! Reply with quote

Everybody who sees this thread, share the things that annoys you the most about this game and what you view as serious flaws. I can never seem to find proper rants to popular games on the internet and rants are healthy.

I've been seriously pissed off so many times by so many things in various scenarios. Sometimes unfair, sometimes the conditions are understandable but somehow intolerable anyway, and most of the time I want to complain that the game isn't made the way I want it to be. Confused

I must add I find this game has potential but it's also the only pirate game I've ever played. I do love the concept and lots of things are attractive in it.

Here's my own major complaints (to begin with):
1#
In sea battles, my vessel seems to be reduced to 1 or 2 knots immediately regardless of where the wind goes, how strong it is, what vessel I use, and what position I have. So much for strategy and skill of my own. And if I alter my position slightly too much in the direction of my target, the vessel "brakes" and "reverses" 1 or 2 knots. What the hell is up with that? Are sea battles supposed to be that retarded? Should it really take forever when sea battles are the major thing in a game like this?

2#
Even if I use the fastest ships like a (fully repaired) Sloop or a Frigate, still my ship is too slow when chasing a spanish War Galleon across the sea. That's completely inconsistent. War Galleons against the wind should go very slow, and playing with a higher difficulty level isn't an excuse for messing with rules and logic. It seems that ships that are classified as "fast" are only a little bit faster in sea battles, but not on the adventure map which of course is a pile of deceitful rubbish. Moreover if I need to store chargo and lots of food I always need an extra ship and the bigger the fleet the slower journey, so it doesn't matter. Yes I've tried to use a fleet only consisting of Sloops, it still goes slow tailwind. Especially going east against the wind. Going east is always walking in deep mud and stalemate winds really tests your patience but not your skill.

3#
Save scumming. I doubt the designers of the game where too stupid to realize a player can find a treasure or a lost relative by cheating. Acquiring the first map piece and save, and then get the others to see where it's located and load the game, thus saving both money and time. Time is money in this game, wasting time means aging and losing the patience of the crew aswell as food, I don't got time to visit every port to pay 2000 bucks for a complete map that shows the location of a treasure worth say 3-4-5000 and wasting so much effort to get a few extra thousand gold. Save scumming isn't a game strategy, it's cheating due to the insufficient design of the game, and if I really want a productive career on a higher difficulty level I find myself forced to.

4#
Getting items from a creepy perv with a retarded voice in every corner of every tavern that looks the same but somehow is suppose to be "mysterious". What's up with pestering me with Ruby Rings and information on ports I've already visited? I need important items that improve the quality of my adventure. Things I need first are things I look for. As plain absurd as it is, I could eventually find the item I'm looking for by going in and out of the same port again and again and again because that oh so mysterious tavern dude seems to have an endless supply of things I could use in particular. How convinient. How about having a shop in every port where I can choose to buy these items and the price vary depending on the port? Jesus christ. I need this or that item NOW! Can't afford for waiting for it to randomly show up. And why buy when I can dance my way to it? Yeah those cutsie little Dancing Slippers are really manly and in character for pirates huh? I'm so glad I have to waste money just to get rid of the offer, in order to get the item I really need. Can the game get more unconstructive?

5#
Animations are tedious, repetitive, goofy, silly, cartoonish and deject any grownup individual trying to take his own experience with the game seriously. Have you seen the like of "fencing" like in this game? While picking at the graphics, you can't customize your pirate and it always have to be this gentleman pussy who fights certain always-the-same-people with a personal vendetta. Why not be able to choose to include the revenge thing or not in my characters mission? Why not be able to customize him with a beard, or certain clothing? Oh yeah I forgot, I actually CAN dress him up.... in cute feather hats and dancing slippers and nice little puffy shirts. What is this guy, an overclass lady?

6#
The indian settlements doesn't help me find lost cities which whereabouts they should know of. And the items that "help my relationship" with indians and priests are completely ineffective and waste money if I buy them, and if I don't, it takes up space and time in terms of having to decline those items when they show up, once again testing my patience on more than one level.

Overall, Sid Meier's game tends to force feed you complete and utter bullshit, despite the game at its core is a good idea.[/i]
_________________
A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity....
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Rusty Edge
Rigger
Posts: 1977



2992 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Jul 31, 2014 6:44 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I'd agree that it's good to rant about what you don't like.

As you might imagine, we here are die-hard fans who mostly love this game. We have devised new goals, and learned a lot about gameplay.

You are not the first to voice some of these concerns, and there are mods here that might be to your tastes.

Actually, it sounds to me as if you might prefer the game in alpha over at STEAM, "Caribbean". There's a thread on it in our OTHER GAMES section.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
scandinavian
Powder Monkey
Posts: 24


1618 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Jul 31, 2014 6:57 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Rusty Edge wrote:
I'd agree that it's good to rant about what you don't like.

As you might imagine, we here are die-hard fans who mostly love this game. We have devised new goals, and learned a lot about gameplay.

You are not the first to voice some of these concerns, and there are mods here that might be to your tastes.

Actually, it sounds to me as if you might prefer the game in alpha over at STEAM, "Caribbean". There's a thread on it in our OTHER GAMES section.


I don't know where to look for others complaining about it, like I said, I usually only find reviews that describe a game but not real opinions or rantings. And the pile of threads in here are huge, I wouldn't know where to look for others complaining. I've already reached the level of "Bishop" at Rogue level and feel I'm done with the game, I've beaten it, and I should play others before this faulty mess that is Sid Meier's Pirates drives me insane. I'll check that one out, thank you!
I've even heard it had to be released before it was properly finished.
_________________
A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity....
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Rusty Edge
Rigger
Posts: 1977



2992 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Jul 31, 2014 8:17 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

As I often say, a game is meant to be fun.

I doubt if the mods and advice here can change Pirates! enough to turn insanity into fun for you.

Me, I like the random elements in games, I think they make the challenges more varied, and the games less predictable and more replayable.

I like to solve incomplete maps. I like to capture Ships of the Line. I like to find new ways to play Pirates!

Nice to meet you, Scandanavian!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Jul 31, 2014 8:38 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

If sloops and frigates are too slow and sluggish for you, then try a war canoe. Even if you don't want to use the canoe for fighting, you can use it as your flagship to drag the rest of your fleet around the Caribbean. Your fleet speed depends only on 1) the speed of your flagship, and 2) the number of vessels in the fleet. It matters not at all whether those other vessels are war canoes or fluyts - only their number matters.

I don't do a lot of naval combat - I usually just try to board as quickly as possible and then fight like a man with my sword. But those who do use a system of raising and lowering their sails to facilitate turning. In short, reefing your sails facilitates turning, even though it might reduce your forward speed.

I never buy an item that I can get for free from a daughter. Early in the game, I don't buy any items at all - except the dancing boots/shoes, which help me to get the other items from the daughters. Those calfskin boots might be the most useful item in the game - and there is nothing effeminate about them. Purchasing the more useless items can wait until late in the game when I am flush with gold and my crew is content.

If an opponent taunts you about your silk fencing shirt, a quick thrust to his torso will shut him up!

Most of the repetitive elements of the game correspond to tropes from pirate literature. Just read a pirate story or two, and the game will make more sense. Here is a list of popular pirate novels. I can recommend Captain Blood, by Rafael Sabatini.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Mr. Blue
Rigger
Posts: 1947



79905 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Jul 31, 2014 11:28 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

There is a 3rd factor that effects sailing speed, I think, and that is damage to your sails/rigging. I think that any damage to any ship in your fleet slows you down, because if the damaged ship is not your flagship, then you will keep having to slow down when a "Wait for me" message appears over the damaged ship.
_________________
" ... the mistakes that we male and female mortals make when we have our own way might fairly raise some wonder that we are so fond of it. " George Eliot
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Mr. Blue
Rigger
Posts: 1947



79905 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Aug 01, 2014 12:30 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

I wonder if you would like Port Royale. I haven't played it in years, but I think it had a more real feel to it than Sid's Pirates. Not so cartoony. Mind you, its almost as much a business simulation as it is a pirate game. There are opportunities to build your own businesses, and trade is more realistic.
_________________
" ... the mistakes that we male and female mortals make when we have our own way might fairly raise some wonder that we are so fond of it. " George Eliot
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Aug 01, 2014 12:55 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Mr. Blue wrote:
There is a 3rd factor that effects sailing speed, I think, and that is damage to your sails/rigging. I think that any damage to any ship in your fleet slows you down, because if the damaged ship is not your flagship, then you will keep having to slow down when a "Wait for me" message appears over the damaged ship.

You are, of course, correct. I think hull damage might also slow you down if it is extensive.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
sparticus
Helmsman
Posts: 6957



58741 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Aug 01, 2014 1:36 am    Post subject: Re: What frustrates you about Sid Meier's Pirates! Reply with quote

scandinavian wrote:

2#
Even if I use the fastest ships like a (fully repaired) Sloop or a Frigate, still my ship is too slow when chasing a spanish War Galleon across the sea. That's completely inconsistent. War Galleons against the wind should go very slow, and playing with a higher difficulty level isn't an excuse for messing with rules and logic. It seems that ships that are classified as "fast" are only a little bit faster in sea battles, but not on the adventure map which of course is a pile of deceitful rubbish. Moreover if I need to store chargo and lots of food I always need an extra ship and the bigger the fleet the slower journey, so it doesn't matter. Yes I've tried to use a fleet only consisting of Sloops, it still goes slow tailwind. Especially going east against the wind. Going east is always walking in deep mud and stalemate winds really tests your patience but not your skill.


Get yourself a war canoe - and use that as your flag ship when sailing, your fleet will go that much faster.

A skilled player can take down a Ship of the Line with a War Canoe.

And it is a lot of fun as well.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
scandinavian
Powder Monkey
Posts: 24


1618 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Aug 01, 2014 2:31 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Rusty Edge wrote:

Me, I like the random elements in games, I think they make the challenges more varied, and the games less predictable and more replayable.

I like to solve incomplete maps. I like to capture Ships of the Line. I like to find new ways to play Pirates!

Nice to meet you, Scandanavian!


But if you choose skill at Medicine to prolong your years, the skill I use to choose, and use save scumming, eventually you will get all things regardless of how random they are. I just don't buy that. And once you get a ship of the line, what's next? Doing it at Swashbuckler level and becoming a Governor? No I feel I've explored all the interesting enjoyable parts that are the bulk of the game. Perhaps I could find the fourth lost city but unfortunaley this fearful dreaded treasure hunter uses the method of itsy bitsy tiptoe to get his clues. Not my cup of tea. Another suggestion; a pirate competitor like Kidd or Bonnet could have a piece to the map which you retrieve when you beat them. What do noble ladies know of lost treasure that my kind don't??

Nice to meet you too Rusty Edge. Sailor
_________________
A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity....
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
scandinavian
Powder Monkey
Posts: 24


1618 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Aug 01, 2014 2:53 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Roland wrote:
If sloops and frigates are too slow and sluggish for you, then try a war canoe. Even if you don't want to use the canoe for fighting, you can use it as your flagship to drag the rest of your fleet around the Caribbean. Your fleet speed depends only on 1) the speed of your flagship, and 2) the number of vessels in the fleet. It matters not at all whether those other vessels are war canoes or fluyts - only their number matters.


There you go. The shortcomings of this poorly designed game are the inconsistency and lies. Ships like Trade Galleons are suppose to travel slow, so why does this rule magically bend because I happen to have a different kind of flagship? This isn't true, I've had Brigs as flagships followed by Sloops, all of them having full hit points, all of them having cotton sails, all of them going tailwind, still I get "wait for me" and a feel of going not faster than usual merchant ships. There are no excuses.

A war canoe is nice, I tried to use one at one occasion a few days ago. I wanted to find out who that last 1 single crewmember was, so I got down to 20 crew, captured several war canoes and let my ships go straight into reefs to sink them and killing my own crew until I had 1 dude left in 1 war canoe. I couldn't form land partys below 10 crew members so I got all the treasures I wanted, then did this, and divided the plunder. My crewmember wasn't me left in the boat, it was another guy who got the larger share of the plunder. The crew got 127000 gold and me 54000. By the way, how can I have 8 specialist and a cabin steward named Montalban in my crew if my crew is below 10?

"But those who do use a system of raising and lowering their sails to facilitate turning. In short, reefing your sails facilitates turning, even though it might reduce your forward speed."

Appreciate the tip. I know, it seems to be the only way to get around this. But the -1 knot or -2 knots never appear on the overworld view. My ship never stops except from in the sea battles, so there's something fundamentally wrong with how the game designers were planning this thing. Lately I wanted my Brig to go fish a barrel that flew off a damaged Galleon. My ship literally stand there, not moving at all, while that damn barrel was RIIIIIIGHT in front of my ship. I just sat there yelling "pick up the barrel, pick up the barrel" while the Galleon just sailed away. How on earth can a sea battle get so fucked up and straight down retarded? Why can I not pick up a goddamn barrel with a Brig, and how can a damaged Trade Galleon outdo me because of that?

"Early in the game, I don't buy any items at all - except the dancing boots/shoes, which help me to get the other items from the daughters. Those calfskin boots might be the most useful item in the game"

But here's another complaint (the failures of this game never ends). To get rid of the need of dancing equipment, I choosed Wit and Romance as skill once, just to find out what happens without the boots. But guess what? I can't marry, because that duelor who protects the lady is so lightning quick - while all other captains at sea are no match in the same game - that I'm defeated regardless of what I do and I lose the lady. So why the hell would anyone choose that useless skill, when FENCING is the ONLY way to get a lady to marry you and share lost city maps in the end?! This is beyond excuse and Sid Meier is a moron.

"Purchasing the more useless items can wait until late in the game when I am flush with gold and my crew is content."

Your crew gets more content if you got 3-stringed fiddle to begin with and I also need a Dutch Rutter to use my map better and plan my future career, aswell as protection like a leather Vest so my character doesn't go limb. The earlier one gets the Medicinal Herb and Mystic Salve the longer the adventure gets. I think. Or perhaps it doesn't matter and I need to retire at age 50 regardless of when I get the healing items, as long as it's earlier than age 42.

"If an opponent taunts you about your silk fencing shirt, a quick thrust to his torso will shut him up!"

This game is weak sauce, my character never kills anyone. They all jump into the water or surrender. If I wanted to shove my opponents I could just go for a big stick and a shield. The game is clearly made for minors.
_________________
A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity....
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Rusty Edge
Rigger
Posts: 1977



2992 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Aug 01, 2014 3:46 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

scandinavian wrote:
Rusty Edge wrote:

Me, I like the random elements in games, I think they make the challenges more varied, and the games less predictable and more replayable.

I like to solve incomplete maps. I like to capture Ships of the Line. I like to find new ways to play Pirates!

Nice to meet you, Scandanavian!


But if you choose skill at Medicine to prolong your years, the skill I use to choose, and use save scumming, eventually you will get all things regardless of how random they are. I just don't buy that. And once you get a ship of the line, what's next? Doing it at Swashbuckler level and becoming a Governor? No I feel I've explored all the interesting enjoyable parts that are the bulk of the game. Perhaps I could find the fourth lost city but unfortunaley this fearful dreaded treasure hunter uses the method of itsy bitsy tiptoe to get his clues. Not my cup of tea. Another suggestion; a pirate competitor like Kidd or Bonnet could have a piece to the map which you retrieve when you beat them. What do noble ladies know of lost treasure that my kind don't??

Nice to meet you too Rusty Edge. Sailor


Well, like I said before, games should be fun and I don't think we can make this fun for you.

It was designed to be playable by kids. That's why it's cartoony, and tells the story of a boy. That's why there's no blood, and why people surrender or go overboard rather than die. I rarely re-load a game, unless it's to learn what I "should have done".

I liked your story about sharing out the loot with one sailor. In Real Life, a navy or a pirate captain was entitled to a limited share. According to pirate bylaws, they would have to pay off the dead and wounded pirates first, but shares are shares, and the captain would not get more than the crew. One of the Horatio Hornblower stories has a part in which Hornblower escapes France with his cox'n Brown in a small ship they stole from the French. As the only official crewman ( they used prisoners at gunpoint to raise the sails) Brown got rich, and was able to buy a tavern.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Aug 01, 2014 4:03 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Different vessels have different sailing characteristics. A sloop with a tailwind will never go full speed. With a sloop or a pinnace, you want the wind coming across your bow at a right angle (which is realistic for a fore-and-aft-rigged vessel). A frigate is faster with a tail wind.

Wit and charm is my usual skill now at all levels except Swashbuckler. I need the help with dancing, and the early access to beautiful daughters is also useful. Except against Montalban and the English captain of the guard, I win all swordfights at Rogue, so I don't need fencing.

If you can't beat tough opponents consistently with your sword, then you are playing at too high a difficulty level for your skill. To get better at swordfighting, download the Fencing Academy - a series of savegame files at different difficulty/equipment/age levels that allow you to practice fencing against challenging opponents.

You are right about the medicinal herbs and mystic salve - those are two other items to buy at first opportunity. But governors' daughters are eager to gift you with all the fencing items and the rutters.

The game is aimed at all ages. My nephews loved it when they were younger. The cartoonish, unrealistic violence helps to make it suitable for the kids. If you want to see more blood, then this is not the game for you.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
scandinavian
Powder Monkey
Posts: 24


1618 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Aug 01, 2014 10:36 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Cool story Rusty Edge!
_________________
A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity....
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
scandinavian
Powder Monkey
Posts: 24


1618 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Aug 01, 2014 11:03 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Roland wrote:
Different vessels have different sailing characteristics. A sloop with a tailwind will never go full speed. With a sloop or a pinnace, you want the wind coming across your bow at a right angle (which is realistic for a fore-and-aft-rigged vessel). A frigate is faster with a tail wind.

Wit and charm is my usual skill now at all levels except Swashbuckler. I need the help with dancing, and the early access to beautiful daughters is also useful. Except against Montalban and the English captain of the guard, I win all swordfights at Rogue, so I don't need fencing.

If you can't beat tough opponents consistently with your sword, then you are playing at too high a difficulty level for your skill. To get better at swordfighting, download the Fencing Academy - a series of savegame files at different difficulty/equipment/age levels that allow you to practice fencing against challenging opponents.

You are right about the medicinal herbs and mystic salve - those are two other items to buy at first opportunity. But governors' daughters are eager to gift you with all the fencing items and the rutters.

The game is aimed at all ages. My nephews loved it when they were younger. The cartoonish, unrealistic violence helps to make it suitable for the kids. If you want to see more blood, then this is not the game for you.


I suppose I can study and remember more of the sailing characteristics of the ships. I feel I want to add that thing when it goes too fast, and I'm trying to leave a tight shore or a settlement placed in a tricky way, and the fleet can't get out to sea without hitting shore. If I want a ship that goes fairly fast both against the wind and with the wind, what ship do you recommend?

You also win the swordfight against the "jealous duelor" when your skill is Wit and Charm on Rogue? Do you make perfect dances or just average dances? I only dance to get items, and in that case I need those that improve my fencing abilities. Though I don't know if the dance is worth it, since the daughter might just tell me where Raymondo is instead when I'm not even looking for that guy. Raymondo is a special guy, he is able to get away from a fight by only leaving a piece of a map instead of the entire map when I threaten to kill him if he doesn't reveal my relatives, and when the fight is over he magically teleports to another place in the Caribbean. I guess some people just have it easy. And when one of these antagonists are defeated at sea, I get spanish pirate-hunters after me despite I just captured other pirates and not innocent merchants. Interesting logic. I get punished for doing what the game pressures me to do.

But again, when I played this, I could manage all swordfights EXCEPT the duelor. Which is inconsistent and an unfair surprise. I managed Montalban at sea and captain of the Guard aswell. I didn't buy/was rewarded with any puffy shirts, vests or balanced swords but relied only on my own skill and I could deal with it. I felt I needed a challenge. But sometimes this game doesn't offer you proper challenges, but either wimpy bullshit or impossible bullshit, and it's not shy about being blatantly absurd in its own random taste for it.

After having played this to a sufficient amount I can safely conclude it's only meant for kids who don't want to look into deeper aspects of a game. That's why this game doesn't contain any deeper aspects that really stand the test of time, and it's why I think, one usually doesn't find objective probing assays in reviews of games in this style, because gamers are most often brats looking for short little fun and want to defend their shortsighted game world at all cost. It almost doesn't matter how much a game sucks, they will praise it as mindless drones and pretend it's meant to be that way.

I love the land battles because they are the only pure scenario that generates the feeling of a serious game. There's no funny business, you play it like chess and rewarded properly for doing a good job. At sea, you might do hours of hard work capturing merchant ships, but if some insane pirate-hunter defeats you, you lose the fruits of all your hard work. And don't tell me I didn't plan ahead - getting bombarded in many sea battles results in damage that makes me more and more handicapped.
That's the reason I keep to conquer cities, because it's safe and proper and consistent. I've done it all, sacked Havana and Vera Cruz and Panama and installed French or Dutch governors there. I've attacked all the inland ports, when I did Panama I marched with 400 sailors against 500 soldiers and got 20 000 gold. THAT is satisfying gameplay. It works and is enjoyable and I have a good reason to feel I've accomplished something. Very Happy
_________________
A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity....
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Pirates! Chat All times are GMT
Goto page 1, 2, 3, 4  Next
Page 1 of 4

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group