Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

Massive Invasion--only with me there to catch it??
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> General Hints and strategies Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3  Next
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Oct 20, 2006 12:49 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Hawkins wrote:
In my game, it is now March 1686. Campeche, Villa Hermosa, Vera Cruz, have remained English since I first captured them (yes, I do look at the map frequently and, out of my interest in the subject at hand, I've been paying close attention to the status of the three Gulf of Mexico cities). For a very, very long time they have all three been Prosperous with garrisons between 120 and 180, though Villa Hermosa did recently drop to Modest with a garrison of 100.

Now, that is 17 years so far of those cities belonging to England, during which I've been around them for roughly 10 months. (I have not divided the plunder in that time, BTW.) They have, that entire time, had garrisons small enough to be easily captured by an invasion force.

Re-reading this post from earlier in the thread, I noticed you said you looked at these cities on the map frequently to keep tabs on their prosperity and garrisons. Are you aware that city info is not updated unless 1) you go near the city or 2) the mysterious stranger in a tavern give you an intelligence report on the city?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Cussler
Cutthroat
Posts: 371


2686 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Oct 20, 2006 4:05 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Roland wrote:
Cussler wrote:
Hmmm...I think Roland, you are misinterpreting what I and perhaps Hawkins were getting at.

You don't have to be near the target, you just have to see the ship anywhere.

No, I understood what you and Hawkins were saying. When did I suggest you had to be near the target?


When you mentioned the pop up notices informing the player if an invasion/troop transport/ new governor reaches a destination. Since you only receive these notices if you are near the target and not when they occur far away, I thought that's where some sort of misunderstanding was coming from.

Quote:
As I understand it, if a ship that passes within your viewing range subsequently does something significant - e.g., deliver (or fail to deliver) a governor, immigrants, troops, or a treaty; sack a city; or capture a city - an announcement will appear on your screen. So even if you do not notice such a ship, you should still receive notification of its activities. Under your hypothesis, therefore, if you pay attention to these messages, you should never be surprised by a city's changing hands.

This suggests the question: Is it possible for a vessel to pass close enough for you to enable it to capture a city, but not close enough to result in your being notified of the capture after it happens?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Hawkins
Powder Monkey
Posts: 28



1650 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Oct 20, 2006 4:07 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Roland wrote:
Re-reading this post from earlier in the thread, I noticed you said you looked at these cities on the map frequently to keep tabs on their prosperity and garrisons. Are you aware that city info is not updated unless 1) you go near the city or 2) the mysterious stranger in a tavern give you an intelligence report on the city?


Nope, I'm not "aware" of that because it's not true.

While the economies of those cities have been stable, I _have_ seen small fluctuations in the garrisons, e.g. gain 20 soldiers here, lose 20 soldiers there. Nothing dramatic, but changes nonetheless. Also I saw them all become prosperous (they were, of course, poor after I originally captured them), then saw Villa Hermosa drop to Modest, and more recently Vera Cruz has dropped to Modest as well.

Now, I was vaguely open to the extreme possibility that I'm getting all this from the mysterious strangers--I'll admit that, at this point in my game, I am simply clicking through the strangers without paying any attention to what information they're giving me. But it doesn't seem right that I'd be getting information on those 3 cities _that_ frequently.

Fortunately, it's a ridiculously easy thing to test, so I tested it just now to make sure I'm not crazy.

I went back to a save near Port Royale, sailed up to Cuba and stopped at a Pirate base. I sent the pirates toward Port Royale, which currently had a garrison of 500 soldiers. With that garrison, I expected the pirate attack would fail and leave Port Royale's garrison much smaller.

As I left the pirate base, I sailed north, toward Grand Bahama (and thus further AWAY from Port Royale). I paused the game to check my map every 5-10 seconds or so. When my ship got to around half way between Nassau and Grand Bahama, I saw on my map that Port Royale's garrison dropped from 500 down to 260. So the garrison-reducing result of the failed pirate attack was updated on my map, probably immediately after it occurred, and my map was updated despite the fact that I was neither near Port Royale, nor had I stopped at a port to talk to a mysterious stranger.

Feel free to test it yourself.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Oct 20, 2006 5:07 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

I don't check garrison sizes often, but I make a lot of money buying and selling cargo (especially in the Lesser Antilles, where islands a few days apart can have wildly divergent prices), so I check prices a lot. I am often surprised by significant differences between the prices I find by clicking on the map and the ones I actually encounter in the port when I arrive a few days later. If I don't get updated info, the prices shown on the map will remain as they were at my last visit to that port. The same with the city's wealth level. I find it surprising that military info remains up-to-date when economic info does not.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Oct 20, 2006 5:18 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Cussler wrote:
When you mentioned the pop up notices informing the player if an invasion/troop transport/ new governor reaches a destination. Since you only receive these notices if you are near the target and not when they occur far away, I thought that's where some sort of misunderstanding was coming from.

I was under the impression (perhaps mistaken) that you received notification of the results of missions of vessels you had sighted, even if their destination was far away.

In the same way that you are suggesting that sighting a vessel activates its mission, I thought that sighting the vessel flagged it for notification of the outcome of its mission. I did not realize it was distance-dependent.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Oct 20, 2006 8:26 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Last night I started up Pirates for the first time this month and experimented a bit with event notifications and info from the map.

When you click on a city on the map, garrison sizes do fluctuate quite a bit, but prices do not. It appears that the update criteria for these two pieces of data are different. I did find an additional thing that triggers an update prices on the map: When you are notified of an event that changes the city's wealth level (e.g., arrival of a new governor), you also get updated prices. (I guess the idea is that if you get one piece of news from the city you can get more at the same time.)

Once I saw pirate raiders headed for both Maracaibo and Gibraltar. I hung around Rio de la Hacha, on the other side of the peninsula, to see if I would get the notifications. I was notified of the attack on Maracaibo, but not the one on Gibraltar. But I could tell that the attack on Gibraltar had occurred because the garrison dropped from 260 to 140. So that proves my understanding of the criteria for receiving an event notification was wrong. (Thanks, Cussler, for setting me straight.) It also gives some idea of the radius within which you receive notification of an event.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Hawkins
Powder Monkey
Posts: 28



1650 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Oct 21, 2006 12:51 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Well, the city information includes these variables:

Nationality
Economic level
Population
Garrison size
Prices

(And of course there's info like attractiveness of Governor's daughter and type of ship upgrade available, but that stuff is static within a given game, not variable.)

Of those things, I have very specifically, without a doubt, seen automatic changes on the map for: Nationality, Garrison, Population, and Economic Level (just in case for that last one, I repeated the pirate test I mentioned in my last post, but this time sent the pirates to a town with a smaller garrison; I saw it's economy change from Modest to Poor on the map at about the time I would have expected the pirates to arrive).

That leaves prices, which I haven't tracked enough to be sure about. I definitely see price changes automatically updated when economic status changes, but I'm willing to accept the possibility that price changes within the same economic level might not be updated automatically.

But it's the other things, which do update automatically, that are relevant for the points I've been making. In particular, if any of the Gulf of Mexico cities in my game were captured or had their economies reduced to Poor by pirates, I would see it on my map.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Hawkins
Powder Monkey
Posts: 28



1650 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Oct 21, 2006 4:13 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Okay, I've finally decided to do a more thorough test and hopefully put the nails in the coffin of this argument. The experiment is simple in conception and execution, but boring and tedious. Smile

My hypothesis: The game causes small, incremental changes to happen to cities independent of player involvement but, without the player witnessing any ships spawned by the game, drastic changes from these types of ships do not take effect:

Invasion Forces
Pirate Raiders
New Governors
Immigrant Transports
Troop Transports
Indian War Canoes

The method: In my current game (1660 era), I went to a saved game outside Port Royale in March 1686. I sailed to the coast of Louisiana, putting me quite far away from any computer-controlled ship. I sailed back and forth along the coast of Louisiana for several months until January 1st, 1687. This gave me a sensible point from which to begin recording yearly data, and also ensured that any ships that might have come within my viewing range on my way to Louisiana had ample time to reach their target port before I started recording data.

I then typed out a list of every city in the game, and recorded data for each of them (except Gran Granada and St. Augustine, which I have no information on because I have not bothered to visit either in my current game and didn't think to check them until I had already finished the preparation phase of the experiment). The data I recorded were: Nationality, Economic level, Population, and Garrison size. These are all things that I have already confirmed DO automatically update on the player's map.

I then sailed back and forth along the coast of Louisiana, essentially letting time pass, for one year. On January 1st, 1688, I checked all the cities on the map again and recorded all changes. (Also I did check the map a few times during the year, just to scan for drastic changes, to reduce the possibility of something like England taking Santo Domingo and Spain grabbing it back within the year without me noticing.)

This was a nice setup, because if my hypothesis is wrong, it should be VERY easy to disprove, or at least place in doubt. I would consider even one city changing nationalities as disproof of my hypothesis, and furthermore any of these would cause extreme doubt:

*Any city changing economic level by more than one level, indicating possibility of a pirate raid or new governor.
*Any city gaining or losing a significant (at least 100) number of garrison troops), indicating possibility of troop transport or failed attack by indians or pirates.
*Any city gaining or losing a significant amount of population, especially if the gain is in multiples of 1200, indicating immigrant transports, or if the loss is by half, indicating an indian attack.

If none of those things happen, my hypothesis is not necessarily proven, but it's certainly quite strongly supported. It would be quite odd for a whole year in Pirates! to go by without a single new governor, troop transport, indian/pirate attack, invasion force, etc. in the entire Carribean.

Now, there is certainly possibility for error; e.g. a pirate raid could drop a Prosperous city to Poor, and then be immediately followed by a new governor bringing it back up to Prosperous (or even the city just incrementally climbing back up to Modest). Likewise, a Modest city incrementally growing to Prosperous would be indistinguishable from a Modest city getting a new governor. But if these things are going on, one would think those examples would be in the minority, and I should see at least ONE strong piece of evidence against my hypothesis as described above, if not plenty more.

So, what did I find, you're wondering? Without further ado... MY RESULTS:

Out of the 41 cities I kept data for:

None changed nationalities.
None had any change in population size.
22 also did not have any change garrison size or economy.
19 had small changes in garrison size--they gained or lost either 20 or 40 troops. None gained or lost more than 40, indicating they were all most likely incremental changes, and not the result of troop transports or failed pirate/indian attacks, all of which have more drastic effects.
2 cities grew from Modest to Prosperous, representing the only economic changes. Those are incremental changes that do not strongly indicate the possibility of a new governor ship like a change from Poor to Prosperous would have, though the possibility isn't ruled out either.

Those results are close to what I expected, and IMO pretty strongly support my hypothesis. Based on what I'd already seen, I would have nearly crapped myself Shocked if I actually saw a city change nationality, so I wasn't surprised to see it not happen. The minor garrison fluctuations strongly resembled what I already casually noticed in the Gulf of Mexico while I was leaving it alone, so that was no surprise. What did surprise me a little bit was that the populations didn't change at all--I figured the computer would make minor incremental adjustments to population size in the same way that it does with economies and garrisons, but it appears that the computer may not make any changes to population outside of the changes that occur with immigrants, indian attacks, and player attacks (I think I've seen population decreases from my own plunderings, correct me if I'm wrong). Also, I wasn't surprised that no economic levels changed by more than 1 level, but I was a bit surprised than only 2 cities changed at all.

Anyway, when I have the time and motivation to do so, I certainly intend to continue this for more than one year. Hopefully my 57 remaining crewmembers will be able to shrug off the fact that they haven't had anything to eat in the past 10 months and will be able to focus on the joy of scientific research (and the 1 million or so gold coins filling up my little war canoe, the Bloody Hell). Twisted Evil
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Tom Pullings
Gunner
Posts: 530



11279 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Oct 21, 2006 4:40 am    Post subject: Weakened attacker? Reply with quote

This is a really interesting thread. I have wondered about this but not been sure. It does seem to me that the game reacts to the player's presence, whether defined by viewing area or other notice or contact. At the same time some internal rules seem to operate. For example, the originating city must have enough prosperity to support the invasion. And it seems that the invasion subtracts from the strength of the city spawning the invading fleet on some formula, though perhaps not a straight numerical subtraction. I have passed cities too strong to attack (this was in the west Carribean) and then intercepted and captured or sunk invasion fleets that originated from that city. Returning, I found the city weak enough to attack. It almost seems that the cities build strengh depending on rules that may operate in the player's absence, and then, when the player returns to the vicinity, are more apt to expend the strength in invasions. I am not sure that invasions can't also occur according to some rules in the player's absence (though maybe I just didn't "see" the events when I could have), but it definitely seems more apt to happen when the player is present. That's the beauty of computers, I guess - the environment can be shaped by complicated, multivariable rules.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Hawkins
Powder Monkey
Posts: 28



1650 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Oct 21, 2006 2:31 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

It's true that wealthy cities send out more invasion forces. It's also true that ships sent out by a city can have small effects on the city. Unharmed merchant ships seem to help a city's economy over time. On several occasions, I have seen a city's economic level drop immediately after I captured a merchant ship sailing out of it. I've seen small drops in garrison levels after capturing pirate hunters (actually, I noticed it casually and did not pinpoint whether the garrison decrease happened immediately after the pirate-hunter ship spawned, or if it only happened after I captured the pirate-hunter).

I think it may be possible that, like the ships with drastic effects, the ships with minor effects (i.e. merchant ships) might ALSO not have their effects applied without being "seen" by the player. That's too hard to test, though.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Hawkins
Powder Monkey
Posts: 28



1650 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Oct 21, 2006 3:17 pm    Post subject: Results from Year 2 Reply with quote

I've completed a second year of my experiment and recorded the data. The second year changes are remarkably similar to the first year changes, with the biggest difference being that more cities experienced small economic changes.

Here are the results:

None changed nationalities.
None had any change in population size.
19 also did not have any changes in garrison size or economy.
21 had small changes in garrison size. Again, all changes were up or down by 20 or 40 soldiers, with one exception--Havana, which increased its garrison by 60. (Its change was still definitely incremental though... I noticed it had increased by 40 midway through the year, and then another 20 at the end of the year.)
5 cities changed economic levels (all by only 1 level, as before, and as expected). 2 (2 of my Gulf of Mexico cities, actually) went from Prosperous to Wealthy, 1 from Poor to Modest, 1 from Modest to Prosperous, and Caracas now has the distinction of being the first city in my data to DROP an economic level, from Prosperous to Modest.

Some fun facts, now that I have 2 years of changes to compare to each other:

- Change (or lack thereof) in garrison one year didn't seem to correlate with change in the other year. Some cities lost then gained, some gained then lost, some lost both years, some gained both years, some gained/lost one year and had no change the other, etc.
- No city changed economic levels both years. So, 7 cities have changed by 1 economic level in 2 years, 6 going up and 1 going down.
- All but one change in economic level was accompanied by a corresponding change in garrison. 5 economic gains were accompanied by small garrison gains, the 1 economic loss was accompanied by a small loss in garrison size. One economic gain was not accompanied by a change in garrison, though it was preceded by a garrison increase in the previous year.
- Havana has experienced the most change in two years, with its garrison increasing first from 220 to 260 in year 1, and then to 320 in year 2, and its economy changing from modest to prosperous in year 2.

So far, the data is still strongly supporting my hypothesis. In 2 years I've seen no hint of successful invasion forces, indian raids, or immigrant or troop transports. I've also seen no hint of failed invasion, pirate, or indian attacks. Though they can't be quite as easily ruled out, I've seen no strong evidence of new governors or successful pirate raids (defined, respectively, as a poor city jumping to prosperous or a prosperous/wealthy city dropping to poor).

When the mood strikes me, I'll collect one more year of data, but if I don't find any anomolies then I don't see much point in going further, other than seeing what long-term trends (if any) the cities might have when the player doesn't interfere. Alternative hypotheses that fit my data, or attempts by others to do similar experiments, are more than welcome.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Oct 22, 2006 12:52 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

And I thought I was a compulsive research geek! Good work, Hawkins!

Two questions occur to me:

1. Is it possible that most auto-generated missions fail because they are intercepted by privateers? If you're playing at Swashbuckler, where three privateers can be sent to stop governors and immigrants, they might require your active help to get through. (What level are you playing at?)

2. What do you think causes the changes in cities' prosperity levels? Is it just the result of small incremental changes, as with garrison levels? Or do trade vessels complete their missions even when the player is absent? (I realize your answer would be speculative, but it would at least be informed speculation.)
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Hawkins
Powder Monkey
Posts: 28



1650 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Oct 22, 2006 2:15 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Roland wrote:
And I thought I was a compulsive research geek! Good work, Hawkins!

Thanks. Very Happy

Quote:

1. Is it possible that most auto-generated missions fail because they are intercepted by privateers? If you're playing at Swashbuckler, where three privateers can be sent to stop governors and immigrants, they might require your active help to get through. (What level are you playing at?)


I'm playing at Rogue level. Privateer ships only spawn for player-generated mission ships. The only dangers to prevent auto-generated missions from reaching their destinations are the player and "raider" ships from enemy nations (not to be confused with "pirate raiders", which only go for cities and leave ships alone). Only a rather small percentage of ships encounter and get sunk by enemy raiders.

Almost all the auto-generated mission ships I've seen (and not captured myself) safely reached their destination.

Quote:

2. What do you think causes the changes in cities' prosperity levels? Is it just the result of small incremental changes, as with garrison levels? Or do trade vessels complete their missions even when the player is absent? (I realize your answer would be speculative, but it would at least be informed speculation.)


Good question. I originally assumed that merchant ships _do_ have their effect without the player seeing them, but I'm not certain. Two years of data aren't enough to be certain of this, but so far it appears (with 6 cities getting wealthier and only one dropping and economic level) that the general trend is for cities to grow wealthier in the player's absence. That would fit with merchant ships having their slow, gradual economy-improving effect, but it's just as possible that the game is causing gradual changes to occur independently of ship activities.

And then there's the city that dropped an economic level. How did that happen, if only merchant ships are taking effect, and merchant ships generally improve economies? An enemy raider, perhaps--a ship type that hasn't even been mentioned so far. But I have seen raiders drop cities' economic levels often enough to think that, if they were taking effect without me around, then far more than one city in two years would have taken an economic hit. So that leads me back to the idea that the game is doing something somewhat random and independent from the ships.

Whether or not the game is causing these small changes concurrently with trade ship effects, or instead of, I'm really not sure. The only way I could think to test it would be to pick a cluster of 3 or 4 cities, plunder them so they have room for growth (unless they're already modest or poor), make them belong to the same nation, and then:

Sink any special mission ships in the area, while making sure you spot as many merchant ships as possible and let them get to their destinations. If one of the cities raised more than one economic level in 2 years (and especially if more than one of them did), then it would appear merchant ships improve economies faster than they're improving when the player is not around to see the merchant ships. Hence, merchant ships aren't taking effect if players don't see them.

If the economies didn't improve faster, then you're left back at square one... it could be working either way. Confused
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Hawkins
Powder Monkey
Posts: 28



1650 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Oct 24, 2006 12:31 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Before sitting through a third year to collect my last set of data, I decided to take advantage of the situation I was in--having saved games two years apart, during which I have not seen a single ship aside from my own valiant war canoe.

Earlier, while discussing the updating of information on the in-game map, Roland mentioned seeing prices at a port suddenly change from the info on his map when he got close enough to the port (or received information from a "mysterious stranger").

In my mind there are two basic possibilities:

1. The information really isn't updating automatically, even though all other city information does.
2. The information is updating automatically, but ships entering and leaving the port cause changes as the player approaches, causing the illusion of the map's information having been wrong.

I'm pretty sure I've seen the second happen, but I'm still open to the first.

I picked out four cities that hadn't changed economic level in the two years, and compared their prices in Jan. 1687 to Jan. 1689. My map did show changes in prices--though fairly small, usually differences of 1-3 gold pieces. So, apparently the map was updating information in some way, but that doesn't necessarily mean the currently showing price would be the same when you reach the port.

So, I loaded my 1689 save and sailed to Campeche (the closest city that hadn't changed economic levels) to see if my prices were up-to-date. As I approached Campeche, I saw a golden opportunity to repeat Cussler's anecdote, which I'll mention in a separate post. To make a long story short, after a few tries, when I managed to get into Campeche without a new governor or pirate getting there just before I did, the prices were the same as the prices shown on my map.

I guess that's why the mysterious strangers don't charge money for their information like they do in the classic Pirates! games. Rolling Eyes
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Hawkins
Powder Monkey
Posts: 28



1650 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Oct 24, 2006 12:39 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

So, I loaded my save from Jan. 1 1689, the end of my 2 years off the coast of Louisiana. I headed for Campeche, and was lucky enough to spot a New Governor ship ahead of me (I was only able to see it approaching the city with the forward-looking view). It was 11 weeks out of the English settlement it spawned from, and I saw it in late January, so it should have spawned well before my saved game.

So, I reloaded my game multiple times--at least 5--and sailed as quickly as I could to Campeche, and each time I watched the same New Governor ship sail into Campeche and turn it from Prosperous to Wealthy on January 26th or 27th.

Then I reloaded my game multiple times without sailing to Campeche--just waiting for January and February to pass. Campeche stayed prosperous each time. I also tried sailing to Campeche after delaying a little bit, essentially giving myself just enough time to "miss" the New Governor ship. I'd arrive at Campeche, still prosperous with no evidence of having a new governor.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> General Hints and strategies All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3  Next
Page 2 of 3

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group