
The Problem with Pirates (too easy)
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
SubDivi

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 30 

 
842 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon May 23, 2005 11:40 pm Post subject: |
|
|
When I think "small ship", I think Sloop. When I think "tiny ship", I think Pinnace. I understand how multiples or even a single small ship could overthrow a Galleon - in order to do that they would have to, however, cut down as many men as possible before they got on-deck. They couldn't just rush on deck outmanned 3:1, they'd get slaughtered before they even got to unsheath their cutlasses.
Even though it's possible, taking down much larger vessles with much more men would require more strategy than just shooting in, fencing a captain, and having the rest of the men surrender.. and no pirate in their right mind would go around taking on a large ship head-to-head in a cannon battle which I know some of you do.
I'd like to see some of these indian engineers though. Making a canoe that can withstand several cannon volleys, let alone one or two cannon shots? Must be that "ingin magicks" I keep hearin' 'bout. _________________ Some men bring home the bacon - I choose to bring home the booty. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
rupertlittlebear

Helmsman 
Posts: 4434 


10417 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 12:06 am Post subject: |
|
|
| SubDivi wrote: | When I think "small ship", I think Sloop. When I think "tiny ship", I think Pinnace. I understand how multiples or even a single small ship could overthrow a Galleon - in order to do that they would have to, however, cut down as many men as possible before they got on-deck. They couldn't just rush on deck outmanned 3:1, they'd get slaughtered before they even got to unsheath their cutlasses.
Even though it's possible, taking down much larger vessles with much more men would require more strategy than just shooting in, fencing a captain, and having the rest of the men surrender.. and no pirate in their right mind would go around taking on a large ship head-to-head in a cannon battle which I know some of you do.
I'd like to see some of these indian engineers though. Making a canoe that can withstand several cannon volleys, let alone one or two cannon shots? Must be that "ingin magicks" I keep hearin' 'bout. | Double check your assumptions.
http://hookedonpirates.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=1631 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
fossaman

Gunner 
Posts: 717 

 
3515 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 12:25 am Post subject: |
|
|
Besides, wood floats, remember? Very rarely did a ship actually sink during the era of wooden ship construction. Usually it happened in storms or whatever, when the ship could be filled with water. Even if a ship caught fire, it would usually burn down to the water line but stay afloat. _________________
Like my fossa? He's a pirate!  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
rupertlittlebear

Helmsman 
Posts: 4434 


10417 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 12:44 am Post subject: |
|
|
| fossaman wrote: | | Besides, wood floats, remember? Very rarely did a ship actually sink during the era of wooden ship construction. Usually it happened in storms or whatever, when the ship could be filled with water. Even if a ship caught fire, it would usually burn down to the water line but stay afloat. | Now as I recall . . .
Classical sailing ships are more than wood with a mast and sail.
The problem of the wind in the sail was commonly solved by something . . . you know, wind pushes sail, sail flips over ship . . . now what was it again . . . now let me think . . . oh yes, now I recall . . .
Lead ballast. Tons and tons of it.
Yep, wood floats, ships sink. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
fossaman

Gunner 
Posts: 717 

 
3515 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 12:56 am Post subject: |
|
|
Really? I thought that that was what the keel was for. However, I was mostly replying to SubDivi's comment that it would be unlikely for a canoe to survive a cannonball. It might take on a bit of water, but it should still float. _________________
Like my fossa? He's a pirate!  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
SubDivi

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 30 

 
842 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 12:59 am Post subject: |
|
|
I was aware of your post, Rupert; what you called my 'assumption', I think, was most likely my attempt at sarcastic humor. Unless there was something in that post that pointed to how the "War Canoes" historically survived several cannon shot. Reguardless of historical accuracy, I don't think they should even be able to fire a single cannon let alone 8 cannons, and theres also the durability of the thing. Exactly how many round shot can those things take before they're splinters? _________________ Some men bring home the bacon - I choose to bring home the booty. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Yellowbeard

Seaman 
Posts: 201 


7885 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 2:08 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | This directly implies that even you agree that the War Canoe was intended as a fighting ship in this game. |
Well of course War Canoes are intended to be fighting ships in Sid Meier's Pirates! That's been my complaint all along!
Just because a game designer intends something, doesn't make it right, realistic, or anything close to the way things should be.
Rupert I know you are one of the War Canoe Jockeys... there is nothing wrong with taking the easiest way of playing the game and exploiting it. It's just that not everyone else thinks sailing around in an Indian War Canoe taking on Ships of the Line with 30 men against 300 is in the "spirit" of what a TRUE Pirate should be.
You want to be an Indian War Canoe Jockey, more power to you, but that shouldn't be the easiest way to play the game (as it is now), it should be the INSANE man's way of playing the game. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Wolfwood

Boatswain 
Posts: 2484 

 
33917 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 2:51 am Post subject: |
|
|
[quote="rupertlittlebear"] | Wolfwood wrote: |
That sounded a bit different to what I read, but might be the same incident. The placade that I read at the museum wasn't too specific... Still, I don't remember there having been any references to any anchored ships or some such... | Have no idea if it is the same incident, but it is similar in nature and flies in the face of conventional wisedom.[/quote
That's true. From this evidence it is clear that pirates _did_ use very light craft when they attacked other, many times larger, vessels.
Of course, these stories also indicate that the vessels were used in quick approach and boarding/sabotaging actions. Whereas in Pirates! they carry several cannons and are, basically, not really "canoes" as such.
Smaller craft, such as sloops, usually used small or medium carronades instead of real cannons because of the stress that the heavier weapons would but the whole hull through when fired. _________________ It is much better to be armed with a sword that has two edges than with an estoc [...], which is nothing more than a stick with a point. (Rapier Master G. Morsicato Pallavicini, La Scherma Illustrata, p. 14.) |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
rupertlittlebear

Helmsman 
Posts: 4434 


10417 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 4:53 am Post subject: |
|
|
| SubDivi wrote: | | I was aware of your post, Rupert; what you called my 'assumption', I think, was most likely my attempt at sarcastic humor. Unless there was something in that post that pointed to how the "War Canoes" historically survived several cannon shot. Reguardless of historical accuracy, I don't think they should even be able to fire a single cannon let alone 8 cannons, and theres also the durability of the thing. Exactly how many round shot can those things take before they're splinters? | You clearly did not read the link. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
rupertlittlebear

Helmsman 
Posts: 4434 


10417 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 4:54 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Yellowbeard wrote: | | Quote: | | This directly implies that even you agree that the War Canoe was intended as a fighting ship in this game. |
Well of course War Canoes are intended to be fighting ships in Sid Meier's Pirates! That's been my complaint all along!
Just because a game designer intends something, doesn't make it right, realistic, or anything close to the way things should be.
Rupert I know you are one of the War Canoe Jockeys... there is nothing wrong with taking the easiest way of playing the game and exploiting it. It's just that not everyone else thinks sailing around in an Indian War Canoe taking on Ships of the Line with 30 men against 300 is in the "spirit" of what a TRUE Pirate should be.
You want to be an Indian War Canoe Jockey, more power to you, but that shouldn't be the easiest way to play the game (as it is now), it should be the INSANE man's way of playing the game. | You are right, the fact that similar vessels were use to effect historically means nothing. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
SubDivi

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 30 

 
842 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 5:30 am Post subject: |
|
|
| rupertlittlebear wrote: | | SubDivi wrote: | | I was aware of your post, Rupert; what you called my 'assumption', I think, was most likely my attempt at sarcastic humor. Unless there was something in that post that pointed to how the "War Canoes" historically survived several cannon shot. Reguardless of historical accuracy, I don't think they should even be able to fire a single cannon let alone 8 cannons, and theres also the durability of the thing. Exactly how many round shot can those things take before they're splinters? | You clearly did not read the link. |
I did, unless you mean the one that had information I can't read. Really I don't even know what part you're disagreeing with. Instead of trying to be smug, tell someone straight up. For all I know you might have misread my wording or I may have misrepresented my thoughts. _________________ Some men bring home the bacon - I choose to bring home the booty. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
rupertlittlebear

Helmsman 
Posts: 4434 


10417 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 5:40 am Post subject: |
|
|
| SubDivi wrote: | | rupertlittlebear wrote: | | SubDivi wrote: | | I was aware of your post, Rupert; what you called my 'assumption', I think, was most likely my attempt at sarcastic humor. Unless there was something in that post that pointed to how the "War Canoes" historically survived several cannon shot. Reguardless of historical accuracy, I don't think they should even be able to fire a single cannon let alone 8 cannons, and theres also the durability of the thing. Exactly how many round shot can those things take before they're splinters? | You clearly did not read the link. |
I did, unless you mean the one that had information I can't read. Really I don't even know what part you're disagreeing with. Instead of trying to be smug, tell someone straight up. For all I know you might have misread my wording or I may have misrepresented my thoughts. | Since that link explains what a "war canoe" really is, it is still obvious that you did not read it.
As it is another European design, along the lines of a Pinnace and a Main Runner, it could withstand some cannon fire, as all European designs could withstand some cannon fire.
Now I challenge you to come up with some images/designs of Carribean war canoes.
I also challenge you to read the link. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Grimmelshausen

Cutthroat 
Posts: 278 

 
1811 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 9:46 am Post subject: |
|
|
| rupertlittlebear wrote: | | fossaman wrote: | | Besides, wood floats, remember? Very rarely did a ship actually sink during the era of wooden ship construction. Usually it happened in storms or whatever, when the ship could be filled with water. Even if a ship caught fire, it would usually burn down to the water line but stay afloat. | Now as I recall . . .
Classical sailing ships are more than wood with a mast and sail.
The problem of the wind in the sail was commonly solved by something . . . you know, wind pushes sail, sail flips over ship . . . now what was it again . . . now let me think . . . oh yes, now I recall . . .
Lead ballast. Tons and tons of it.
Yep, wood floats, ships sink. |
Stones. It was usually stones used as ballast. Though sometimes the stones were replaced by silver or gold chests. Drake did that on the Golden Hinde, when he circumnavigated the world. He had captured so much gold his ship couldn´t have carried it, so he tossed the ballast stones overboard and replaced them with chests of gold and silver. So did Morgan after his raids on Maracaibo and Panama.
A ship could sink, but to sink them was really hard. The Revenge, Drake´s flagship during the battle against the Armada, fought against over fifty ships in her final battle, but it didn´t sink in that battle. It fell apart in a storm when being towed by the Spanish, who captured her. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Yellowbeard

Seaman 
Posts: 201 


7885 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 3:07 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | You are right, the fact that similar vessels were use to effect historically means nothing. |
You are right... a single occurance in hundreds of years of Pirating, surely means it's the norm, not the exception... silly me.
I'll bet your car has a bumber sticker that says "You can take my War Canoe from me when you pry it from my cold dead fingers".  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Wolfwood

Boatswain 
Posts: 2484 

 
33917 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 4:08 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Hey guys, let's be a bit kinder to each other and let the facts do battle, not the people.
1) It is generally known that pirates used small and light craft in their trade, because they could then easily escape into the shallows if they were pursued.
2) Also, they almost always went after merchant ships, which means that they did not expect there to be a lot of opposition from the crew in the form of cannon battle (merchant ships generally did not have enough crew to work the cannons properly, let alone trained gunners). As such, small and light craft were probably the smartest choice: you do not give time to the slow crew to shoot their cannons more than once or twice.
Conclusions:
1) In Pirates! the Game you don't have musketmen to defend the ships, or to take out defenders prior to the boarding. Instead, we have even the lightest of craft sailing with cannons. Given that the game is full of abstractions anyway, we can presume that the cannons not only represent the cannons used in battles, but also the musket fire.
2) Real pirates did not attack pirate hunter ships, or other military ships except probably by mistake (since camouflaging the ships to look like something else was a widely used tactic on both sides). Their light craft could not have withstood a real battle-hardened crew of a professional fighting ship, nor would they have been able to merely scare the soldiers by their mere appearance as they often did the crews of regular merchantmen. _________________ It is much better to be armed with a sword that has two edges than with an estoc [...], which is nothing more than a stick with a point. (Rapier Master G. Morsicato Pallavicini, La Scherma Illustrata, p. 14.) |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|