
How neat are fleets?
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Capt Peter Blackthorne

Cutthroat 
Posts: 312 

 
1784 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon May 16, 2005 6:14 pm Post subject: |
|
|
That's a good point, Yellowbeard. In your experience, which kind of ship(upgraded with copper plating and cotton sails) makes the best cargo hauler? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Yellowbeard

Seaman 
Posts: 201 


7885 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon May 16, 2005 6:46 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | That's a good point, Yellowbeard. In your experience, which kind of ship(upgraded with copper plating and cotton sails) makes the best cargo hauler? |
Biggest bang for the buck (most cargo for least crew), which usually means an East Indiaman or Treasure Galleon... whichever comes first.
I know what you're thinking, they're slow, but only if you use them in battle (I never do)... once upgraded with at least cotton sails, they ALWAYS keep pace with my fleet and never slow me down (I usually have a Frigate or Sloop as my flag). An East Indiaman or Treasure Galleon with cotton sails will always keep pace with your flagship and both hold 140 tons of cargo for only 24 crew.
I generally sink prize ships unless they have cotton sails and are undamaged. My Treasure hauler has plenty of room in it's hold for lots of seized goods and I can stay at sea a long time without returning to port... of course having three warships adds even more cargo space... but by minimizing damage to any one warship (rotating my warship duties) and having a huge upgraded treasure-hauler, I can stay at sea for a long time without a need to go to port or sacrificing speed of the fleet.
Give me my undamaged, upgraded Treasure Galleon or East Indiaman any day over some damaged wool-sailed prize ship that needs to be taken to port immediately... I'll stay at sea plundering and gaining rank!
One final advantage about being able to stay at sea longer and with a large cargo capacity plus good fleet speed... I don't HAVE to dump-off cargo at the closest port... by staying at sea I can be choosy as to which port I dump my cargo off at, which usually means to the highest bidder, increasing my voyage's profits!
Shiver me timbers!  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Mycroft Stanyer

Seaman 
Posts: 145 

 
2709 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon May 16, 2005 7:15 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Yellowbeard wrote: | ... by staying at sea I can be choosy as to which port I dump my cargo off at, which usually means to the highest bidder, increasing my voyage's profits!
Shiver me timbers!  |
So long as that merchant's gold till holds out. If you clear out a Merchie's 3000 gold with plenty of cargo left over, it defeats the whole "I'll sell it all in one go".
Fleets are always slower than lone wolves, no matter the consort, no matter the upgrade. Try tacking your way from Cuba to the Windwards with East Indiamen taking the wrong corner with each turn the whole journey through. The whole fleet slows in order to preserve stationkeeping, and the larger the fleet, the more attention to stationkeeping they pay. Damage, even spread about among the fleet, magnifies the effect. That is if, of course, should you forgo the use of cargo vessels and opt for smaller consorts to do battle each turn (then again, greater crew demand and lower overall cargo capacity as compared to a fleet of Treasure prizes).
Or does one really slug it out riding a Treasure Galleon? Only if you're a swordfighter, fully commited to forsaking naval combat at all and just boring straight in for a boarding action.
Frankly, I can't see the swordfighting in the game as close to anything being balanced ("Oh, no! One of my 230 crewmen just got slain by one of the 89 enemy sailors! My concentration and combat speed will suffer greatly now!"). And there's not much fun in the "ignore the cannonballs raking through my bowsprit and ram them head-on so I can swing an oversized tableknife instead" tactic of gameplay. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Yellowbeard

Seaman 
Posts: 201 


7885 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon May 16, 2005 8:28 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | Try tacking your way from Cuba to the Windwards with East Indiamen taking the wrong corner with each turn the whole journey through. |
That would actually occur if the game made any sense, but as you pointed out in other arguments, the game rarely does this.
I've tacked my way from Mexico to Cuba both with a single Pinnace and a fleet of ships including Indiamen and Treasure Galleons. So long as your flagship is the same vessel and any ships in the fleet are all upgraded with cotton sails, it doesn't matter a bit if you're a single Pinnace or a Pinnace leading a fleet of seven treasure galleons... it moves the same speed... try it, I did!
Instead of your fleet matching the wind ability and speed of your slowest ship, the reverse is almost true where the slow ships match the speed of the fast ones. The only time this doesn't occur is if you have a DAMAGED ship, or an UNUPGRADED ship.... then you slow down.
A Treasure Galleon that is upgraded and undamaged which is led by a flagship Pinnace will move just as fast as a Pinnace on it's own... does it make sense? No... Does it happen in the game... YES!!!
I would not be sailing the seas while including Galleons in my fleet if they slowed me down... but they ONLY slow you down if damaged, unupgraded or in the lead... so long as they are undamaged and upgraded and your flagship is something else, those Galleons and Indiamen will make GREAT speed.
Maybe you're thinking of unupgraded prize ships, damaged galleons or an East Indiamen in the lead... instead try it with healthy upgraded ships with a fast Sloop or Pinnace as the flagship. There is no speed differance in this case!
Why not try it instead of assuming they are slow based on logic alone. I'm telling you straight up, under the right circumstances, a Galleon or Indiamen will sail just as fast back from Mexico as a Pinnace in this game!
That's a FACT.
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Mycroft Stanyer

Seaman 
Posts: 145 

 
2709 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon May 16, 2005 8:44 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I have made observations into fleet movement versus the speed of lone wolves. I have, riding a Frigate leading a fleet of undamaged, upgraded Sloops on a tack into the wind on Hispainola's south coast, rounding the diamond peninsula between Petit-Goave and Santo Domingo...
The fleet came to a near stop, despite the fact that my Frigate was actually hauling while close on the beam reach. She should have been going. The whole danged fleet should have been going. But the first three ranks of the fleet had to back to a stop while the last rank crawled— straight into the wind— to get into the proper formation at the wings of the chevron. Slow as a Fluyt in the face of a 1-knot breeze.
Three Brigs of War, toddling around the islands and into the Gulf of Mexico. I ditched the two consorts in Campeche and broke out of the Gulf alone because no matter how fast the flag was sailing, one consort would fall behind, then pop back up with a little "burst of speed". Or was it the perceptual illusion one gets when the leading ships slow down.
My observations have always been the slower ships "pulling away, springing back", a mark of their differing speed. Can you trust your observations enough to say that the slower ship "speeds up", or is it that the faster ships "slow down"? Remember that the camera is going to keep your flagship centered onscreen— everything moves around it. You don't get any real sense of the ship moving around everything else.
I have hop-scotched a Cotton-sailed Galleon along with a Brig, because the Galleon consistently lagged behind while the Brig shot ahead. Switch flags at the long point of a "stretch" so that the Brig could cover the lagged distance behind. Otherwise, the Brig in lead slows down to let the prize catch up. Always has. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Yellowbeard

Seaman 
Posts: 201 


7885 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon May 16, 2005 9:27 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | Can you trust your observations enough to say that the slower ship "speeds up", or is it that the faster ships "slow down"? |
The slower ships speed up in fleets led by fast ships. This much I know.
Besides trying fast ships alone and fast ships with "slow" ships... I did other experiments.
I had a fully-upgraded Treasure Galleon... the exact same one that was mixed in with a fleet of upgraded fast ships... I noted speed going from port to port under certain circumstances (wind direction/speed, etc) of the Galleon being led by fast ships.
I then went to port, sold off all my fast ships and then used the fully upgraded Galleon by itself to go from the same port to port as had just been done, using the same conditions (using save-game files).
The exact same treasure galleon using the exact same route in the exact same conditions became much, much, much slower then it ever was before and could NEVER match it's speed when sailing alone compared to when other fast ships were in the lead.
This proves the fact that slow ships speed up in fleets to match the flagship, not the reverse... the only time the fleet as a whole slows down is when you have damaged ships or unupgraded ships.
Is it logical? No... does it happen... Yes!!! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Mycroft Stanyer

Seaman 
Posts: 145 

 
2709 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon May 16, 2005 9:32 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Yellowbeard wrote: | ...I had a fully-upgraded Treasure Galleon... the exact same one that was mixed in with a fleet of upgraded fast ships... I noted speed going from port to port under certain circumstances (wind direction/speed, etc) of the Galleon being led by fast ships.
I then went to port, sold off all my fast ships and then used the fully upgraded Galleon by itself to go from the same port to port as had just been done, using the same conditions (using save-game files).
The exact same treasure galleon using the exact same route in the exact same conditions became much, much, much slower then it ever was before and could NEVER match it's speed when sailing alone compared to when other fast ships were in the lead. ... |
Interesting. Did you repeat the experiment by selling off the Treasure Galleon and timing the run while using a single fast ship?
That is to say, did presence of the Treasure Galleon slow down an otherwise fast boat? You never quite said that.
I never have taken a prize that was both upgraded with Cotton sails and was undamaged. Taking a prize with undamaged sails is the mark of a fellow who doesn't dare let off even a warning shot at his prey, choosing instead put his best nose forward to ram-n-board. Anyone who opts to win a ship by pressing one of six buttons in timed, coordinated sequence isn't demonstrating keen fighting ability unless we're speaking about Street Fighter. Finding the maneuvering solution to the positioning problem— fighter pilots do it. Iron men of wooden ships did it as well. When I come aboard a prize, I come aboard a dismasted hulk with rivers of blood sloshing in the scuppers.
If we were going up against human-controlled ships in this game, the whole ram-n-board option would not be open to you unless the other fellow was keen on doing it that way himself. Any other fellow would keep his distance and rake you with chain and roundshot until your ship began looking like a coleander, then rake you down with grape until there was 1 crewman left before boarding. Under those conditions, no one of sound mind (or a successful career) would want to engage a battle with an East Indiaman or a Treasure Galleon under their feet. Choosing to do so because the game's AI is too stupid to exploit that poor decision is hardly indicative of any mastery in ship-to-ship combat. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Yellowbeard

Seaman 
Posts: 201 


7885 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon May 16, 2005 10:44 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | That is to say, did presence of the Treasure Galleon slow down an otherwise fast boat? You never quite said that. |
Believe me... this very question got me running a battery of tests... an upgraded Frigate by itself ran just as fast as the fleet... I'm telling you, the Galleon sped-up to match the Frigate, not vice-versa.
As for prize ships and sword fights and what-not... I actually agree with you... you're confusing me for a Canoe jockey who does little more then board and fight.
That is the EASY way to do things, but I actually prefer blowing large chunks out of my opponents with large ships like Frigates. As for my upgraded/undamaged Treasure Galleon:
A) It's NOT a prize ship!
B) I blew it up good, took it to port, fixed it up, upgraded it, renamed it... made it permanent ship in my fleet
C) I sink any ship that I damage and/or that is not upgraded... my fleet Treasure Galleon can keep any goods I plunder
I enjoy a good broadside over a sword fight. This is why I keep my own treasure-hauling ship, so I don't have to worry about prize ships slowing me down.
To this end, I ran significant tests on what exactly slows a fleet down, and what does slow a fleet down is un-upgraded and/or sail-damaged ships. A fully upgraded Galleon that is undamaged will actually INCREASE its speed to keep up with a fast flagship... sail it alone, and it crawls like molasses. My fast ships are NOT slowed down by an upgraded Galleon, so long as the fast ship is the flagship.
Once again, I'm not saying this is the way it should be, I'm simply stating this is the way it actually is in-game. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
mangojuice

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 10 

 
137 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue May 17, 2005 8:18 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Lots of good discussion here about prize ships.
Personally, I have definitely noticed that even a fleet of fast ships can be slowed down just because they're a fleet. Even heading in a good direction relative to the wind, the fleet isn't quite synchronized (especially when you're tacking) so you do have to wait for stragglers sometimes.
I may be fairly alone in this, but I always try to get myself a war canoe with cotton sails fairly quickly, because (1) this basically doesn't put any drag on my fleet (nor does it take much extra crew), and (2) having a war canoe with cotton sails makes it SO much easier to catch those pesky small ships, some of which are quite worth it. Personally, I go after every war canoe I can find because they basically never even hurt me, and they give up without a fight, plus all four nations love it when you kill indians, which leads to ranks and land a plenty. But on top of that, smugglers and immigrant ships are often small. Also, I really like using a war canoe against fast pirate-hunting ships, because I really don't like being out-maneuvered.
Personally I have rarely noticed enough of a difference in price to make it worthwhile holding on to goods at sea even if it only slows you down a little bit. Usually, I have to go halfway across the caribbean to get a price 50% higher than what I can get locally, which just isn't worth it... EVEN if I'm already heading there -- what if I pick up more goodies on the way and need the room? Though one time, I noticed that Sugar in Santiago was at 22 gold per ton, while it was only 5 or 6 in Leogane... with the ships I had, I could make about 1200 gold per round trip... but of course it wasn't really worth it, compared to plundering. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Yellowbeard

Seaman 
Posts: 201 


7885 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue May 17, 2005 10:48 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | Personally I have rarely noticed enough of a difference in price to make it worthwhile holding on to goods at sea even if it only slows you down a little bit |
Holding onto goods doesn't slow me down at all. The reason I keep a small fleet is so that I have the luxury of deciding if I'm going to ditch the goods at the nearest port or a richer port along the way to wherever I'm going without having to worry that my hold is overflowing. A problem you always have with a single warship.
Bottom line, maintaining a small fleet allows the luxury of storing larger hauls of goods for longer periods of time and spreading out damage (if need be) to multiple ships instead of accumulating all on one. A single ship, will have to return to port far more frequently then a fleet, either because of prize ships, overflowing holds, or battle damage. Each trip a single ship has to return to port early for is another week my small fleet terrorizes the main and accumulates more while the single-ship's captain spends his time in a tavern getting older.
Every Pirate I have retired (and there have been many) has retired with the full 126 points before turning 40. I have had no need to sail past the age of 40, because by maintaining small fleets I stay at sea long enough and avoid ports for lengthy amounts of time, that I am able to accumulate all I need well before turning the ripe old age of 40. It may not be the best strategy, it is certainly not the only strategy, but frankly, I have no intentions of fighting sword duels till I'm 50. This strategy is sound and works great for me. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed May 18, 2005 10:34 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Looks like fleets can be pretty neat. In the real world of pirates it was difficult enough to fully man one fighting ship. Effectively coordinating attacks with multi-vessels isn't all that easy to do, and naval officers get a lot of training, and experience, before being allowed such a command. It is just as easy to get a ship sunk as to sink ships. While one's attack vessel may be successful, that extra ship might be deep-sixed, even by hapless luck on the other side. Why run the risk? If the one attack vessel works well enough, keeping that second ship out of the action seems only prudent. I can imagine watching a ship go down that I could just as easily have sold, losing what's aboard as well as what profit might have been made.
On the other hand...hook?...if I were a naval officer who had gotten word a "fleet" of pirate ships was on the rampage, I'd probably treat the matter in a warlike fashion. Meaning: Not a pirate hunter on your trail, but a tactical fleet like the one I'd use against a nation's navy. Maybe a low profile works best in the end to avoid an untimely end? _________________
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
b4lazarus

Cutthroat 
Posts: 274 

 
4739 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu May 19, 2005 12:18 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Airsaw wrote: | Effectively coordinating attacks with multi-vessels isn't all that easy to do, and naval officers get a lot of training, and experience, before being allowed such a command.
|
SMP treats the fleet scenario without cause for concern. Apparently anyone under your command can pilot a vessel successfully, even though they do not take part in any sea battles. Fleets, to me is a minor part of the game (SMP) that could have been a major part. I look at additional ships as spares or goods for trading purposes. The added benifit of a larger crew and cargo was never a big plus for me.
On the other hand, the standard for the way a fleet could be amassed was established in "Sea Dogs". The abilities of the captain you appointed to command the additional vessels in your fleet was paramount to a succesful sea battle with other fleets, forts etc. Even though you were limited to 4 ships, if they were outfitted with able seaman and experienced skippers you could rule the Spanish Main.
My two cents about Fleets... _________________ X |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|