Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

What we know about Pirates! 2...
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Pirates! Chat Goto page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Falconer
Captain
Posts: 1839



2865 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Sun Aug 31, 2003 9:56 am    Post subject: What we know about Pirates! 2... Reply with quote

As we've mentioned in the introduction, very little is known about the game at this point.

At this years E3 (the huge game expo held in Los Angeles), Firaxis announced that they would create a sequel to Sid Meier's Pirates. A press release followed shortly after with again, precious little information about the game itself.

In it, we're promised:
- updated gameplay
- 3D graphics
- new features (like forging alliances, several paths to wealth)

We can also derrive that these features remain:
- players play a pirate captain
- exploring the seas
- ship to ship battles
- hand to hand combat
- taking over enemy ships
- raiding forts
- treasure hunting

Some characteristics are spoken about:
- role playing aspects
- fame
- wealth

We also know that the game will use NDL's Gamebryo engine, which is a fully 3D engine that has powered a number of great games like Morowind, Dark age of Camelot and Freedom Force. It has proven not only to be an engine that can produce great graphics, it has also shown great flexibility. So it sounds like a great engine for Pirates! 2.

So, what do you think we'll see in the next Pirates! title? Join in and speculate freely!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
MarkQuinn
Powder Monkey
Posts: 22


460 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Sep 02, 2003 3:24 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

This is in response to the write-up on this site under the link entitled "The Game"

Quote:
From the sounds of things, we may also expect the game to as open ended as it was before, hopefully with a different time scale so that a game runs longer and we don't die at a young age..


Regarding the time scale, I agree that games should (and probably will) last longer, but I hope Firaxis doesn't do away with this part of the game alltogether. The fact that your character aged and got weaker as the years went by created a sense of urgency in Pirates! Gold which has not been duplicated in subsequent pirate titles to my knowledge. There was always a wonderful balance. You started the game at age 25 and by about 35 you were too spent from years of fighting enemies and elements alike. It was always a wonderful decision to be made: do I have that last expedition in me? The upside of aging, however, was that by the time you reached your 30s you would usuallu have developed a reputation which would attract more sailors in droves. Often you wouldn't even have to fight because enemy ships would strike their colors at the mere sight of you. So with aging came that constant choice: do I want to risk everything with one more role of the dice, knowing that my boys will save the day if need be, or do I want to take my spoils and depart from the sweet trade once and for all? The whole story-telling aspect of Pirates! Gold where you began as a poor young hand on a plantation (or whatever story they generated) and ended your career with "The Further Adventures of...." sequence was a cornerstone of the game's appeal. Yes, games should run longer (meaning time should pass more slowly and it should take longer to reach new islands) but the aspect of aging provided you with a more interesting game.

Does everyone remember Cutthroats? In that game you did not age. You could literally play the game a hundred game years or more. Every good game should eventually have an ending. Pirates! Gold of course provided us with the hall of fame screen which ensured that the exploits of our more successful pirates didn't drift away into obscurity, and the designers of Pirates! 2 would be wise to expand that aspect, perhaps with the generation of printable spreadsheets which could track every statistic, plundering and exploit of your character.

Quote:
It would be great if quests would be generated at the start of a new game so that each game will come with new challenges although a main storyline will most likely be implemented.


Gamemakers today have become too storyline happy. I can sit down with my brand spanking new copy of Pirates! Gold for Windows and play an entirely new game, years and years after starting my first game (of Pirates! for the Mac) in the late 80s. It's still all fresh and new to me. Same goes for Cutthroats. Both these games have quests which are nice and welcome, and I'm not even opposed to a main storyline provided it is TOTALLY unobtrusive and only enters into the picture if the player wants it. By contrast to that we have of course Pirates of the Caribbean, a game whose graphics and physics never cease to amaze me, a game which touts itself as totally open-ended, but a game where you have to follow the storyline from the beginning and THEN play somewhat open-ended if you chose. I say "somewhat" open-ended because it's really not. A true open-ended game wouldn't force me to be enemies with the French, for instance, from the outset of the game. Instead --- as in Pirates! and Cutthroats --- I should be permitted to chose my own path. POTC choses much of that path for you. These are the pitfalls game designers run into when they make a game too story-oriented.

I would be very happy if Pirates! 2 played almost identically to its predecessors with the following exceptions: enhanced 3D graphics, more commodoties to steal and trade, a longer time-frame for the game without the absence of character-aging. Of course this forum will certainly generate more wishlists which will be very appealing, but Sid had the perfect formula back in 1987 and I hope his company doesn't mess around with it too much.

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Falconer
Captain
Posts: 1839



2865 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Tue Sep 02, 2003 5:04 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Hi Mark, welcome to the site Wink

Some good points there. The timescale perhaps should be changed (loosened/slowed down) but the retirement part was too much of a presence in the game to be missed in its sequel. (hope Firaxis will be reading this *grin*)

Perhaps "the further adventures of" part could step in after retirement? It would be great if you could for instance set up a trade business on the side or something, that you would run full-time once you retire from privateering. Perhaps that would stray too much from the original idea though and it would definitely complicate things. Sounds cool nonetheless!

I agree with the storyline part in PotC. I liked it, but you can't really stray from it. Even if you would want to, there's not a whole lot to do outside of the main storyline. I'm fairly certain that in Pirates! 2 this will be handled more like the way it was done in Pirates! than in PotC. Sid/Firaxis is known to pay special attention to replayability.

And yes, the formula was good back then and if Civ3 is anything to go on, Firaxis will deliver an experience very close to Pirates! Gold. Wink
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Black Angel
Powder Monkey
Posts: 28


200 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Sep 02, 2003 8:54 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Arggg. I was to young to remember the Pirates! gold game. If i read all this stuff im really really looking forward to Pirates! 2.

I hope there will be some kind of multiplayer in it. To fight side by side against other enemy pirates and make my flag the most feared logo Wink
_________________
Cutlass Isle Staff
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Guest





0 Gold -

PostPosted: Wed Sep 03, 2003 3:34 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

MarkQuinn wrote:
Gamemakers today have become too storyline happy. I can sit down with my brand spanking new copy of Pirates! Gold for Windows and play an entirely new game, years and years after starting my first game (of Pirates! for the Mac) in the late 80s.
I thought the appropriate use of storyline elements was one of the strengths of Pirates!, too. Just enough story elements to tie the game together, not so much as to be intrusive or to force gameplay in a fixed direction. Hope P!2 keeps that balance in effect.
Back to top
PixieButt
Powder Monkey
Posts: 7


303 Gold -

PostPosted: Wed Sep 03, 2003 8:28 pm    Post subject: From a writer's point of view... Reply with quote

The trick to writing a good storyline for a game isn't neseccarily keeping out of the way of the player, but rather making it fun for the audience your writing it for rather than just yourself and a select few others.

The problem with PotC, as was pointed out, was that it thrust you into the world like a baby getting yanked out by the feet: painful and not pleasant. Not to mention that you can't skip that Oxbay scene. At one point I wanted to strangle Knightly to get her to shut up. Also, dispite BethSoft's advertisement that the game was open-ended, the game had to follow a liniar path to achieve goals. Another case of being dragged along kicking and screaming.

The point of a storyline is that it should be there to augment your acheivements, not dictate them.

The storyline should not demand that the player do something about the events at hand.

A story should not lead you where to go and what to do, it should open several opportunities, and not just one at a time.

To jibber jabber a story right in your face while you're trying to do something else is just barking orders, and you're no sailor, you're a captain of a sea vessel! If there are ghost pirates wandering the seas that stole my love, I want to be able to say, "Sorry Trixie, sucks to be you. I'm gonna go sack a few spanish towns and find me wenchs who will do things you never even thought possible.

For example, part of Pirates! GOLD is finding your long lost family members.

Who here remembers finding out the evil Spanish Count Thomas del Montoblan, who knows the whereabouts of your sister, is located in Panama. However, the Spanish Silver Train would be leaving Peru for Santo Domingo at the same time. Oh the decisions. You decide to take on Panama's 600 troops and 4 forts in an epic land battle that leaves your armpits wet and hands trembling, but then you face the fort commander in a duel with your forces weakened. You defeat the commander, and see the evil Count running away. You rush to stop him and challange him. After a long and desperate fight, he gives up the location of your sister, a piece of a map that looks like the shoreline of Gran Grenada. You later find out the governer has fleed the city, but learn that the citizens were aware of your approach and hid most of their valuables. However, you have more than enough goods and gold plundered from defeated Panama, and install an Eglish governer. But you wonder if you can still catch up with the Silver Train, or go after your sister.

Now THAT is a story. That is YOUR story. Not the story of Nick Sharp or Nathan Hawk.

Another problem of storytelling in games is that there is added history between you and other characters that you had no say in. For once I'd like to create a friendship with someone from scratch, rather than "Hey you old sea dog! Remember the good times when we plundered ships and ran away with my wife? Now I get to kill you! But not before you give me the aztec coin!" Now that's an interesting concept, NPCs that remember what you have done for or to them, and react accordingly.

Again, the great thing about Pirates! was that it was YOUR story being told through the game, not the developers' story. After all, which is more interesting? How you and several hundred others sunk the Black Pearl, or your quest to seek the evil Spanish Count Thomas del Montoblan?

I say to game writers who want to live out their fantasies by making us follow them through ghost pirates or international politics, go write a book. At least that way if the story sucks, the gameplay doesn't suffer.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail AIM Address
Falconer
Captain
Posts: 1839



2865 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Wed Sep 03, 2003 8:55 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Hail PixieB!

Damn, I think I found a challenger to my reputation for writing long posts! Smile

But I agree completely and especially back then, in the type of game that Pirates! was (if it could be thrown into a genre/catagory around that time), it was a totally novel approach.

I think it's probably safe to expect this to return in Pirates! 2 and with a punch at that! I think/hope we'll see more/several interwoven storylines that will either run through or make up the main storyline. I think your decisions will also have more of an impact on your reputation and the options/paths open to you.

Of course it remains all speculation at this point, but it's fun to ponder over it with other fans of the game. Smile
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
PixieButt
Powder Monkey
Posts: 7


303 Gold -

PostPosted: Wed Sep 03, 2003 9:19 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Falconer wrote:
Hail PixieB!

Damn, I think I found a challenger to my reputation for writing long posts! Smile


Nah, I just like to hear myself talk Very Happy

Falconer wrote:
But I agree completely and especially back then, in the type of game that Pirates! was (if it could be thrown into a genre/catagory around that time), it was a totally novel approach.


Of course Pirates! can be fit into a genre, it's what we in the writing business call a "Choose your own adventure" genre, without the defined central avatar. Also known as a "Bubble Bath" (more on bubbles below).

Falconer wrote:
I think it's probably safe to expect this to return in Pirates! 2 and with a punch at that! I think/hope we'll see more/several interwoven storylines that will either run through or make up the main storyline. I think your decisions will also have more of an impact on your reputation and the options/paths open to you.


Well, the danger of "interwoven" storylines is that it turns a string into a concrete highway. Rather, it turns a suggestion into a demand, with no alternative. Instead, the optimum way to have storylines (we'll call them quests) in self contained "Bubbles" of action.

You lie outside of these bubbles and make your choice of which ones you want to go into. Some you need to soap your hand up a bit to get into (ie experience of an earlier quest and whatnot). Sure, other bubbles can collect on or around the bubble you are in, allowing different options, but in no way saying "you must enter this bubble to continue". And you can leave the bubble if you want to as well, but some bubbles pop when you leave them.

Pirates! was a "Bubble Bath". The family member quests were bubbles, the treasure fleet and silver train were bubbles, and sacking towns and plundering ships were bubbles. In between you had a ship and a large body of water. The promotions and marriages were rewards from using these bubbles.

Now, bubbles can make reference to each other, that's how other quests inside othe bubbles are found. However, one should not demand the completion of the other, unless the player deems it nesecarry.

As for the main storyline, I maintain that the history of the pirates and politics in the Caribbean is sufficent story enough.

Falconer wrote:
Of course it remains all speculation at this point, but it's fun to ponder over it with other fans of the game. Smile


Indeed it is. Very Happy
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail AIM Address
Butcher
Swabbie
Posts: 66



335 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Sep 04, 2003 2:19 am    Post subject: small Reply with quote

This is just a small suggestion but I hope they keep the turbo function in Smile
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website Yahoo Messenger MSN Messenger
Chuko
Cutthroat
Posts: 275


3730 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Thu Sep 04, 2003 5:55 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Turbo function? what was that I seem not to be able to remember,

Also, I like your analisis of the story line, PixieButt as bubbles (but I cannot remember the silver train ever going to Santo Domingo, in fact, if I can remember correctly, the only time the treasure fleet went to Santo Domingo was in the first scenario, "The Silver Empire" 1560.And another thing, Panama never had 4 forts any time in the game, the most it had was two, once more in "The Silver Empire" scenario. Just nitpicking, I like your naritive though)

Perhaps the forum can create a stories section where people can relive thier tales from the past.

In fact, I still have my copy of Pirates! for the Amiga, transfered for use in an emulator, and I still get hours of play out of it.
_________________
Captian of the Ryokuryuukai!

Status of Ships;
Sloop Syzer sunk, all hands presumed dead
Frigate Sezcka, 28 guns, 260 men
Sloop of War Aozora, 12 guns, 120 men
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
MarkQuinn
Powder Monkey
Posts: 22


460 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Sep 04, 2003 7:11 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

storylines.

Quote:
Who here remembers finding out the evil Spanish Count Thomas del Montoblan, who knows the whereabouts of your sister, is located in Panama. However, the Spanish Silver Train would be leaving Peru for Santo Domingo at the same time. Oh the decisions. You decide to take on Panama's 600 troops and 4 forts in an epic land battle that leaves your armpits wet and hands trembling, but then you face the fort commander in a duel with your forces weakened. You defeat the commander, and see the evil Count running away. You rush to stop him and challange him. After a long and desperate fight, he gives up the location of your sister, a piece of a map that looks like the shoreline of Gran Grenada. You later find out the governer has fleed the city, but learn that the citizens were aware of your approach and hid most of their valuables. However, you have more than enough goods and gold plundered from defeated Panama, and install an Eglish governer. But you wonder if you can still catch up with the Silver Train, or go after your sister.


Wow. What nostalgia. I think I'll dive into it tonight!

Quote:
Now THAT is a story. That is YOUR story. Not the story of Nick Sharp or Nathan Hawk.


I guess it's too much to hope that Akella (a) found this forum and is reading your post, (b) understands the nuances of the English language well enough to comprehend your points (c) cares.

Quote:
Another problem of storytelling in games is that there is added history between you and other characters that you had no say in.


One reason why I love Morrowind. Yes it has a main story and plenty of side quests. They don't force themselves on you though and you are even pursuaded to chose your own path. As far as characters go, you meet everyone from scratch.

Quote:
Again, the great thing about Pirates! was that it was YOUR story being told through the game, not the developers' story. After all, which is more interesting? How you and several hundred others sunk the Black Pearl, or your quest to seek the evil Spanish Count Thomas del Montoblan?


If I want a novel I'll read a novel. If I want a movie I'll watch a movie. The whole point of a game is to give you increased interactive ability. So many games are nothing more than books with pretty pictures and sounds to go along with the plot.

Quote:
I say to game writers who want to live out their fantasies by making us follow them through ghost pirates or international politics, go write a book. At least that way if the story sucks, the gameplay doesn't suffer.


Superb post.

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
LordMacAlpin
Powder Monkey
Posts: 7


200 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Sep 04, 2003 12:37 pm    Post subject: I agrees wit.... Reply with quote

I's agrees wit mi ol' mate Mark on wot de game shoul' be like.I tew am an ol' "Cutthroat" ans play'd "Pirates on mi ol' commodor64 pc fer hours on end.Glad tew see yer still sail'in de cyber seas thar Mark.I's remember dem story lines ye be talk'in abou'.Aye! De decisions ye 'ad tew make made de game IMHO. Wink
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address
MarkQuinn
Powder Monkey
Posts: 22


460 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Sep 04, 2003 5:03 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Great to see you MacAlpin! Any other old Cutthroats you can gather up to sail these seas? Tell 'em if Sid lives up to his name and this game is anywhere near as beautiful as POTC we could be looking at THE gaming event of this century and the last. No joke. No exagerration.

Quote:
De decisions ye 'ad tew make made de game IMHO


I was playing PGFW (Pirates! Gold for Windows) last night and was reminded of several little touches that made that game work so well. For instance, the search for the evil Spaniard which was mentioned on this thread already (In Pirates! I think it was always an evil Spaniard. In Pirates! Gold they spread the evil around a bit and you came across evil aristocrats from all nations). Well last night I started as an English pirate in St. Kitts in 1660 and was of course at war with the Spanish and the Dutch. So there I was cruising just north of St. Kitts picking off those Dutch sloops which were always undermanned but carried nice cargos. You can get into a rut doing that. A fortune is there to be made if you're willing to acquire it methodically, taking the Dutch sloops and fluyts and maybe even sailing further northwest for some Spanish merchantmen. Then back to the English colonies to sell your captured vessels and loot. Why go anywhere else? There's a whole Spanish Main to be plundered but why risk sailing so far from the safety of your English bases? One trip to the governor's mansion answers why.... The prospect of finding that Evil Spaniard, subsequently fidning your lost relative and pushing yourself higher in the end game points is too tempting to continually pass up. In the end we have a REASON to travel further, to visit other ports-of-call. Little things like that made (and continue to make) Pirates! so successful as a game. I could go on.

I notice a new wishlist post was written today. Contrary to my first post where I said I'd like this game to be left essentially the same, I DO have many wishes but am afraid to put too much energy into posting them for fear that they'll never be read by the people who matter (i.e. Firaxis). I am confident that Pirates! 2 will be excellent, but how excellent is the question? At this point I am more hopeful that they don't take away any of our open-endedness and that the graphics will live up to those seen more recently in POTC, which in my mind should be the new standard for seafaring games (despite the total IMBALANCE issues of POTC which make it IMO a very poor game, I find myself returning to it again and again because the atmosphere both on land and at sea seem so accurate, it's more of a daydream simulator for me than a game).

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Falconer
Captain
Posts: 1839



2865 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Thu Sep 04, 2003 7:53 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Not sure if it will be THE gaming event but if Sid indeed lives up to his name, it will definitely be a classic almost from the day it comes out.

The older gamers (25+) may/will remember Pirates! but the newer generation hasn't seen anything of it. Pirate themed games always seem to gather a loyal following quickly but most have become so-called sleeper-hits where the game continues to sell well but doesn't really show on the charts.

With Firaxis track record and Atari's publishing power, this may change dramatically and be the first Pirate themed hit in a long time. Smile

And don't worry about the wish-list. Consider it a nice way to spend time with fellow buccaneers, drinking beer and rum while boasting about each others adventures. As I understand game development (not an expert, but have some idea) whatever we say won't make it into the game at all. With the game due out in less than 7 months, there will be very little design changes made between now and its release.

That's not to say that a addon or sequel won't hold any of the suggestions and with the mod-ability of the Gamebryo engine, who knows how many people will start making cool mods based on the wish lists on sites like ours? Wink
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Butcher
Swabbie
Posts: 66



335 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Sep 05, 2003 1:42 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Chuko wrote:
Turbo function? what was that I seem not to be able to remember,


It was on Pirates! Gold for DOS. You press the T key and it speeds the game up a little bit. Maybe it's official name wasn't Turbo, maybe it stood for time compression or something else. I'm not sure, I just called it turbo.

It was useful for when you go searching for treasures on a big island and it would take a while to walk there with the normal speed. It was also useful for you were sailing against the wind in a big ship, such as a merchantman or war galleon. Just make sure you aren't near any reefs Laughing
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website Yahoo Messenger MSN Messenger
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Pirates! Chat All times are GMT
Goto page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next
Page 1 of 5

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group