
Enduring Alliance
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Fri Jun 16, 2006 7:58 pm Post subject: Enduring Alliance |
|
|
In previous games, I have become accustomed to the ephemeral nature of hostility and peace between the four nations. Countries go to war with each other at the drop of a three-cornered hat for no obvious reason, and they make peace just as quickly and unpredictably. Formal alliances are rare and short-lived.
My current game is a total contrast to the usual pattern. I started in 1660 at the Adventurer level as a witty and charming Frenchman. I found that France was at peace with England and at war with both Spain and the Netherlands, and that the two latter countries were allied with each other. This pattern held with little fluctuation through 1666 - France and England always at peace with each other, and occasionally even allied, versus Spain and the Netherlands, always allied with each other. Now, in 1667, the pattern has finally shifted slightly - France is now at war with everyone, but the Spanish-Dutch alliance still holds.
This enduring alliance between my country's enemies has made my life difficult. Every time I attack a Dutch or Spanish ship (including Montalban and Raymondo, of course), I incur the wrath of both countries. I started the game by capturing a Dutch treasure ship. Three months later, I had yet to attack a second ship of any sort, but the Spanish still regarded me as an enemy the first time I set foot in one of their ports!
In this environment, I had no choice but to take one side or the other, and I was already branded as anti-Spanish/Dutch, so I spent the next few years as a loyal French privateer, racking up favor and promotions with the English and French while watching the Spanish and Dutch bounties on my head rise.
I had accumulated some quests on the Spanish Main, but it wasn't safe to go there with no friendly ports available. So when the abbot offered to propose an amnesty with the Spanish I accepted his offer. Since then I have, with difficulty, maintained the uneasy favor of the Spanish, compensating for my attacks on the EVIL Spaniards by escorting governors and immigrants to Spanish cities and attacking every pirate or Indian I see. Unfortunately, the Dutch still have a price on my head, based almost entirely on my attacks against EVIL Spaniards (I rarely even encounter Dutch ships and haven't attacked one in years).
I just attained the rank of French duke, and everyone now hates France, so it would be logical to turn against France. But I have been in the habit of maintaining loyalty to my starting country. Even when they send privateers after a ship I am escorting, I usually just run away from them to avoid shooting at my countrymen. But that doesn't bring in the gold that my crew craves.
What to do? In the past, I have never bothered smugglers. I figured that I, as a pirate, was in no position to judge those who made their living by skirting the law, and I benefited indirectly from the increased wealth they brought to the cities they traded with (piracy only pays in a world where there are wealthy folks to prey on!). But I am a practical pirate who is now desperate for a rationalization to attack French-flag vessels. Here is my reasoning: French smugglers are traitors who are enriching the enemies of King Louis. By attacking French smugglers, I can damage the economies of France's enemies while currying favor with those same enemies! They will, in effect, thank me and promote me for blockading their ports and enforcing the trade laws of their enemy, France!
I only wish the French governors could follow this logic. Unfortunately, my wit and charm skill is only effective with the governor's daughters, not with the governors themselves. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Jun 19, 2006 7:56 pm Post subject: |
|
|
The alliance between the Spanish and Dutch finally ended sometime in 1668. The new pattern - everyone against France all the time - has held into 1673. Preying on French smugglers got me a bunch of promotions. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Cap'n Scurvy

Swabbie 
Posts: 74 

 
1662 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Jun 20, 2006 6:12 pm Post subject: |
|
|
All that consistency should make it easier, not harder. Just beat up on two countries to get to Duke with the other two, then switch. The harder scenario is when you are beating up on one and kissing up to the other, but the alliances change suddenly, and then change back after you shift your strategy. The easiest way to play is to start out pasting the Spanish, which most other countries appreciate; after you get three Duke titles, switch to the Spanish. Brother what's-his-face even makes it easy for you with his amnesty.
Of course, if you want favor with everybody all you have to do is beat up pirates and indians long enough. _________________ Who doesn't want to be a pirate? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Jun 20, 2006 9:38 pm Post subject: |
|
|
The first problem is that you basically have to attack the EVIL Spaniards to make progress in the game, and the alliance meant that I was always incurring double penalties for every such attack. Therefore, when I finally switched sides I had two holes to dig myself out of instead of just one, and I continued to incur those double penalties for as long as the alliance lasted.
A second problem was self-imposed by my insistence on staying in character: I was reluctant to attack my fellow Frenchmen. The role playing increases the challenge, and for me it's half the fun.
I finally got my Dutch promotion to Duke last night. Everyone has been at war with everyone for several years now, except that the Dutch and English have a stable alliance. Those Dutch must be master diplomats! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Cap'n Scurvy

Swabbie 
Posts: 74 

 
1662 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Jun 20, 2006 9:57 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Roland wrote: | The first problem is that you basically have to attack the EVIL Spaniards to make progress in the game, and the alliance meant that I was always incurring double penalties for every such attack. Therefore, when I finally switched sides I had two holes to dig myself out of instead of just one, and I continued to incur those double penalties for as long as the alliance lasted.
A second problem was self-imposed by my insistence on staying in character: I was reluctant to attack my fellow Frenchmen. The role playing increases the challenge, and for me it's half the fun.
I finally got my Dutch promotion to Duke last night. Everyone has been at war with everyone for several years now, except that the Dutch and English have a stable alliance. Those Dutch must be master diplomats! |
But if the French were always warring with the Spanish, just work on getting rank with the French (and English, while they are still against the Spanish) by attacking Evil Spaniards and the regular Spanish too. And with the Dutch allied with the Spanish and therefore a fair target for you as well, you can pursue a SOTL strategy with them as well (Spanish don't send SOTLs).
Your bigger problem is you are role-playing a loyal Frenchman and not a pirate. I feel the same traitorous twinge when I inevitably turn on my home country (always Dutch), but I get over it when the loot comes in. In the process of being a loyal Frenchman you probably made the French cities rich, so you really cash in when you turn on them.
Plus you know you are likely never getting to 126 points being nice to your home country.
If that doesn't convince you to turn on those Frenchies, just remember the evil captain who beat you up on your voyage to America (leading to your mutiny and your first ship). He was a dirty French bastard!
 _________________ Who doesn't want to be a pirate? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Jun 21, 2006 10:07 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Cap'n Scurvy wrote: | | But if the French were always warring with the Spanish, just work on getting rank with the French (and English, while they are still against the Spanish) by attacking Evil Spaniards and the regular Spanish too. And with the Dutch allied with the Spanish and therefore a fair target for you as well, you can pursue a SOTL strategy with them as well (Spanish don't send SOTLs). |
That's essentially what I did for the first few years - attacking mostly Spanish ships, but the occasional Dutchman as well. The SOTL strategy occurred to me, but none of the three Dutch cities was wealthy enough to produce one. I happily settled for the Frigate that fell into my lap when some overzealous privateers attacked the immigrants I was escorting.
After I made duke with both the French and English, the Dutch-Spanish alliance was still in effect. That meant I was still incurring double penalties for attacking EVIL Spaniards.
Now that the Dutch are allied with the English, I have to limit my attacks against both countries since any such attack will reduce my land grants with both countries. Fortunately, everyone is now at war with Spain!
| Cap'n Scurvy wrote: | Your bigger problem is you are role-playing a loyal Frenchman and not a pirate. I feel the same traitorous twinge when I inevitably turn on my home country (always Dutch), but I get over it when the loot comes in. In the process of being a loyal Frenchman you probably made the French cities rich, so you really cash in when you turn on them.
Plus you know you are likely never getting to 126 points being nice to your home country. |
I limited my French targets to traitorous smugglers, which seemed to work okay, though it slowed my progress.
In all of my games so far I have scored 126 points while remaining loyal to my home country. I am well on my way to doing so again in this game. In each game I have avoided attacking ships of my own nationality, captured at least one enemy city for my country, married a beauty of my own nationality, and retired as governor in a city of my own country. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|