
Dutch Trader
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
crpgnut

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 29 


602 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Dec 02, 2004 3:36 pm Post subject: Dutch Trader |
|
|
I'm going to play a Dutch Trader game and see how much you can earn, by trading, in a career. My goal is to only fight if attacked. I'll try to earn promotions by escorting mayors. My only problem with this type of play is how to acquire the ships I'll need for high volume trading. I need trade galleons, preferably a whole fleet. I'll keep one fighter type ship for protection. My only planned combats will be with Baron Raymondo, Count Mendoza, and Marquis Montalbon. I'm curious as to how much gold can be earned without fighting.
Wish me luck!
I'll probably need it  _________________ 'nut |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
dread pirate roberts

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 44 


1110 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Dec 02, 2004 4:00 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I was wondering the same thing as you. I am getting ready to start a merchant career after my current swashbuckler is done beating down the spanish. I would assume you can hit a merchant ship like a dutch flyut or french merchantman fairly easily, as they have almost no crew. If you have your military escort you could easily get them to surrender I would imagine. Tough to get that merchant fleet without combat, which is too bad. I wish the shipwrights would sell merchant ships to merchants instead of offering a war ship if you only have a merchant ship (have only heard that this happens, have not actually seen it since I am always a pirate.) Let us know how your career goes, and I will do the same after I get going. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
DreadPirateBen

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 6 


294 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Dec 02, 2004 5:00 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Maybe have shipwrights sell only trade ships, so as to help out the traders. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
The Aberdonian

Cutthroat 
Posts: 284 


9964 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Dec 02, 2004 5:22 pm Post subject: |
|
|
i remember i did try that two or three times on the "aulde pirates".... there was - i think - one year where you could start with a fluyte as a dutchman. i just got bored after a short while with that fluyte and was in desperate need to have a bigger trade ship so i nicked a merchantman from the spanish; then i tried to sell some goods in margarita but they did not trade with me any more (=> we don't trade with pirates); anyway, went to trinidad where i could only get 50 gold for tabacco. hmm, smaller profit margin. too bad. i have to get the goods cheaper now but could for that moment only think of the merchantman where i got the stuff for free. and i was still pissed off because margarita refused to trade with me. anyway, got a few hands on deck in barbardos to teach margarita a lesson...
the moment i had hired them i felt like che guevara (he said the moment he put down the medikit to pick up a box of ammunition was the moment he turned from doctor to combatant) because that moment i felt that i have turned from trader to pirate.
Good luck to you!
The Aberdonian |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
tcjsavannah

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 15 


195 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Dec 02, 2004 5:26 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I would also be interested to hear about the success of this type of game.. sure it's fun to blow apart other ships, but my first trading game was the old Taipan on the Apple IIe and I still have a soft spot in my heart for trading games like that. _________________ --
"Welcome to international waters, the land that law forgot." -- Homer Simpson |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Fab

Swabbie 
Posts: 100 


866 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Dec 02, 2004 5:27 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I tried that and found similar problems. First, you have to begin with an attack right off the bat usually if you end up getting a sloop or something as your first ship. I also thought about keeping the military ship as an escort, but I noticed most of the traders in the game are single ships, so I captured a fluyt and then sold my military ship.
I got her all gussied up with copper bottoms (man do fluyts need all the help they can get) cotton sails, and iron scantlings. I didn't buy any letters of marque, I didn't get involved in any national politics, I didn't run any missions (as that's just going to get you into a fight as you know pirates or enemies will attack), I avoided pirates like the plague and I just traded.
It's rough to say the least. A pirate's life is easier than a trader's! Not only do you have to try and keep track of what is being sold for how much and where, but then you have to make sure you're not attacked on the way.
The biggest problems with trading are that 1) you cannot buy ships. I can see not selling war vessels, but buying a fluyt or merchantman shouldn't be hard to do I wouldn't think. 2) You can't get promotions without getting into fights. My goal was to fight once (to get my merchant ship) and then NEVER again. That meant no missions for mayors, nothing. So I got no promotions therefore no girls, no discounts, and so on. 3) Your men want plunder. Making 1000 coin from a successful trade venture doesn't cut it when that same time could have made many times more. I found I had to divide plunder all the time, which means that you spend most of your trading career sitting around waiting for your ship to refit and the like.
I wish there was a way to make the game a little more trader friendly. Perhaps an option to buy vessels, or to keep more than one after dividing the plunder, a way to recruit good crew that aren't in it solely for large returns quickly, and a way to get promoted (maybe not from the nation but from your merchant guild or from the owner of the ship, or at least a way to get the same discounts on repairs and goods that the pirates get).
Ahh well, the game is called Pirates! not Merchants!. I gave up on my attempt after a few years and went back to my regular game of pirating. I found that much more enjoyable. Besides, nothing like that infinite profit margin on stolen goods! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
dot hog

Swabbie 
Posts: 67 


6 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Dec 02, 2004 6:25 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I enjoy pirating, and I'm finishing up my adventurer game as a pirate, but I've tried to do a few trade runs in my waning years. It's not successful and not very enjoyable, for all of the reasons Fab mentioned. I realize that the game is called "Pirates!" after all, but I don't think Firaxis had to add any features or "cheat" on the game they had envisioned to allow merchants a fighting chance at enjoyment.
My main problem is that, from a merchant's standpoint, the game suffers from many imbalances:
1) The "spread" between the offer at one port (the price I have to pay to buy) and the bid at another port (the price I get when I sell) is never large enough to make trading even remotely lucrative. Firaxis avoided realism in most areas to exagerrate many elements, but when it comes to pricing, they exagerrated nothing. They were downright stingy when it came to pricing.
2) The reliance on only one type of crew makes trading impossible. No matter the path in the game you choose for your main character, you are always reliant on blood-thirsty sons of war for crew, and these guys are never happy unless they can fight or they're extremely well paid. As a merchant, you can meet neither of those conditions.
3) The voyages take a long time. This is not a bad thing in general--in fact, I like it--but I don't think it is in the same spirit as the decision to give gamers a negligible spread on goods. I just think it's inconsistent to make gamers sail forever just to maybe--MAYBE--make a 30 gold spread on 50 or 60 tons of goods. That's sometimes as much as 6 months at sea for 1800 gold at best, which is nothing compared to what you get plundering one lousy military payroll on flippin' journeyman. Once you've divided that 1800 (as your crew will be very cranky after one run with no blood), you've wasted a full year just for a couple hundred in gold and no status/fame to show for it. Bummer.
I'm not upset with Firaxis over this--like I said, I realize it's called "Pirates!"--but I think that had they been more consistent across the game, it would be a lot easier for a gamer to take a non-pirate direction and enjoy their career. I don't mind that you have to start "small" and it's tough to run across a decent ship: that seems to me to reflect the fact that merchants needed to have access to big capital to get a decent voyage together. I like that it's tough starting out. What I don't like is that the game doesn't even give you a chance to make the capital you need to get going because of the reasons I mentioned above..
I also think this is one of those situations that is easily moddable: all that needs to be done is adjust the prices at port to allow for a better spread. Furthermore, and I don't know if this is possible, it would be neat if crew could be broken into two types: 1) "docile" crew that are prone to long voyages and more swayed by big plunder payouts, and 2) "hostile" crew that are more interested in a short voyages and bloody battles.
I also wonder if the Tobacco in the game, excluded at the last minute, can somehow be "unlocked" or reintroduced in a patch by Firaxis. Maybe Firaxis intended for the tobacco runs to be the trader's main source of income, and the last-minute exclusion of tobacco ruined that. I understand the business decision to exclude tobacco from the retail version, but I don't see why they can't offer a patch that restores that feature. They're leaving it up to the gamer to decide if they want to download that feature or not, so I don't see how that violates any ratings problems.
Sorry for the long message, but I feel strongly that this is one area of the game that could have been made viable with hardly any effort on Firaxis's end. It wouldn't have ruined the pirating side of things, it would have only given gamers more leeway in deciding how they wanted to live their life in the game. But I guess they want gamers to be pirates--hence the title. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
crpgnut

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 29 


602 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Dec 02, 2004 6:51 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Well, I've been playing as a merchant all morning. It is not a viable character if you want to have any fun. For all the reasons mentioned in the above posts. You can't buy trade ships and even huge cities like Havana can only afford so much cargo. I sold all guns and only carried enough food to move from one port to another. That left me with 35 tons for cargo. Unfortunately, even buying spice at 6-9 and selling it for 30-43 my men were at mutiny level almost constantly. I did give in and went and dug up a buried treasure. That made them happy right up until I was attacked by the pirate we robbed. Needless to say, my gunless sloop was no challenge for his brig of war. My 40 men died before I was able to defeat the pirate and so my career was basically over. Not a lot of fun
My next character will be Rudolph Valentino, french pirate and wooer of all women. My goal in this game is to dance with every govenor's daughter and get 4 hearts in every city. When I'm old, I'll settle down with the beautiful blonde in my Nueve Paris chateau. I figure I'll fight Mendoza 80 times before my career is over It'd be cool if you could marry all 80 women  _________________ 'nut |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Niedzwiedz

Swabbie 
Posts: 123 


1236 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Dec 02, 2004 7:00 pm Post subject: Its not the size of the ship, its how you use it. |
|
|
The trick to a successful merchant career is buying low and selling high. Try setting up a three or four port route that at each stop you can buy something that sells at the other ports for a much higher price. Indian villages are a great source of small amounts of sugar and spice that a small, fast ship can make big profits on. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
crpgnut

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 29 


602 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Dec 02, 2004 7:42 pm Post subject: |
|
|
The problem is cargo space. Even if I buy Spice at 4 and sell it at 35 my profit is less than 1000. I have to buy food for the crew during that time as well and so the profit drops to right at 900. Another negative is that once you've bought sugar or spice from a particular point a few times the value starts to increase. Spice I was buying at 4 is now 8 or 9 on trip four. Unfortunately, at the same time, the merchant that was paying 35 has dropped down to 28. You just can't win by playing small. You have to have a route of about 8 stops. It might be worth retrying this character in the north-south chain between Eustasius and Trinidad. I may just give that a try before Valentino. I will avoid eastern travel with that route which will save time and therefore food consumption. I may get into one fight just so that I can steal a cargo vessel. This way I can kill off all but the necessary crew by extending a duel for a few rounds.
I'll update this post and let you know how this guy works out. _________________ 'nut |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Captain Shadow

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 25 


107 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Dec 02, 2004 8:02 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Here's my opinion...
I don't think Pirates! was designed so you could make a living entirely through trading. It may earn you money, but it won't help you rise among the ranks. Trading is more like a secondary choice. For example, it's good to know where Goods sell high so you go to that port after looting a Merchantman. But I don't think trading is really useful for making anything more than pocket money (or gold, in this case ). |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
dot hog

Swabbie 
Posts: 67 


6 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Dec 02, 2004 8:08 pm Post subject: Re: Its not the size of the ship, its how you use it. |
|
|
| Niedzwiedz wrote: | | The trick to a successful merchant career is buying low and selling high. |
It's more complicated than that. "Buy low/sell high" is based on a mountain of assumptions, none of which are satisfied in the game.
What if you can only flip 20 or 30 tons of goods at every port? Is buying at 5 a relatively low "buy"? And is a resale at 23 gold relatively "high"? Maybe it is to you outside of the game, but in the economy of the game, that "low" buy and "high" sale get you not much of a profit, especially when held against the time it takes to reap that product and the limited amount of cargo you can ship.
There are a lot of factors in the game that conspire to crush the fun of trading: weak spreads, crew that would rather battle than sail, long voyages to take advantage of the "bigger" spreads, and low cargo holds. While I agree with making the path of a merchant tough by having things tough at the outset and limiting the amount of cargo, I disagree with the economy of the game and the nature of the crew. As crgpnut notes, the game is just not fair to the merchant.
In fact, with those prices, I fail to see why any goods outside of guns and food are even necessary to the game. You can't make money off trading 'em. They're only good to be sold when you take them as plunder. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
marichmo

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 20 


803 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Dec 02, 2004 8:31 pm Post subject: It's not that kind of game |
|
|
This wasn't meant to be a trader's game. Port Royale is far superior to Pirates! in that department anyway (The Patrician is even better). In those games you can set up automated trade routes with multiple fleets and even build your own industries to manufacture products for trade. Plus the trade system is dynamic - the sea is full of AI traders (and pirates!) that affect the economic system of each town. Bottom line; Pirates! is very shallow in the "trade-simulation" department and you're better off looking to another game if that's what you're into. Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love Pirates! and its gameplay is a blast, but if you ever get the urge to create a vast merchant empire then Patrician is probably the best alternative. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
crpgnut

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 29 


602 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Dec 02, 2004 8:39 pm Post subject: |
|
|
It is possible to survive as a merchant in the north-south chain. It took 19 months for my crew to get mutinous this time. By buying low and selling high in the 12 or so ports in that area I was able to accumulate the vast wealth of 5,000 in 19 months. Of that 5000, 2200 came from the one fight I participated in to acquire a trade ship. I fought an English merchantman who was carrying a cargo of spice. Note his cargo had more spice in it than all 12 ports combined! Pirates! totally fails as a trade game. IF someone modded the game so that ports had thousands of tons of cargo and the ability to buy trade vessels, then trading would be viable but still very boring. There just wasn't any thought put into that aspect of the game at all. The best way to make that part of the game valid would be to create a thriving black market. Add rum, opium, contraband, etc to all Pirate settlements and add a fence into all major cities. Of course this would mess up the E rating. Next thing you know I'd be asking for prostitutes in Pirate Havens  _________________ 'nut |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
KingWilly

Rigger 
Posts: 1298 

 
9917 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Dec 02, 2004 11:30 pm Post subject: |
|
|
For all those wanting a merchant game, is there a reason why you cannot attack other pirates when you come across them? That way, you may be able to get the larger ships you require, and some free goods, but can also be friendly with all four nations.
I guess it is not a full merchant game, but more of a modified merchant game, but may be an option.  _________________ Shiver me timbers!!!
"It's good to be the king" - Mel Brooks
AKA. Will Scarlett. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|