Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

Equal to the apstles
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Pirate's History
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Mr. Blue
Rigger
Posts: 1947



79887 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Jan 31, 2014 5:29 am    Post subject: Equal to the apstles Reply with quote

I guess Roland is the most likely to be able to help me out here, but go ahead anyone else and put in your 2 cents if you like

isapóstolos (equal to the apostles) is a title assigned in the Eastern Orthodox Church to just a handful of important saints.

As far as I know, Constantine the Great (the first Roman Emperor to become Christian, though some would dispute that) was the first to receive that title (after his death, I think?) and the title was sometimes used by later Byzantine emperors (I think)

OK, so here is my question. Did the title originally begin as a substitute for the Roman custom of deifying emperors? A Christian empire could not bolster imperial authority by declaring dead (or living) emperors divine, but it could bolster imperial authority by placing the emperor (so to speak) at the highest possible non-divine level.

Obviously the concept isapóstolos does not function that way today, but is that how it got started?
_________________
" ... the mistakes that we male and female mortals make when we have our own way might fairly raise some wonder that we are so fond of it. " George Eliot
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Jan 31, 2014 10:30 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

It is true that Constantine and his successors retained some of the divine prerogatives of their pagan predecessors - the person of the emperor remained sacred, and many elements of imperial court ritual continued. In putting himself forth as the earthly representative of Christ, Constantine was behaving much like his predecessor Diocletian (Jupiter) and his nephew Julian the Apostate (Helios).

But I do not think this is tied to the title "Equal to the Apostles". This title is given to saints who were instrumental in spreading the gospel and promoting Christianity. Mary Magdalene is the prototypical isapóstolos, having delivered the news of Christ's resurrection to the apostles themselves. Most other recipients are either rulers who converted their nations (e.g., Vladimir of Kiev, Stephen of Hungary, Boris of Bulgaria) or pioneering missionaries (e.g., Nina, Patrick, Cyril & Methodius). Constantine and his mother Helen easily fall into this category.

Ironically, the Roman Senate deified Constantine after his death!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Mr. Blue
Rigger
Posts: 1947



79887 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Feb 01, 2014 12:02 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Hmm ... Possibly.

You are assuming that the term isapóstolos meant what it means now. The fact that some Byzantine emperors after Constantine used the title even though they would not qualify for it by the standards you mentioned suggests that isapóstolos used to have a political-religious meaning.
_________________
" ... the mistakes that we male and female mortals make when we have our own way might fairly raise some wonder that we are so fond of it. " George Eliot
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Feb 01, 2014 6:31 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Mr. Blue wrote:
Hmm ... Possibly.

You are assuming that the term isapóstolos meant what it means now. The fact that some Byzantine emperors after Constantine used the title even though they would not qualify for it by the standards you mentioned suggests that isapóstolos used to have a political-religious meaning.

I'll have to do more research on this. Can you give me the names of other emperors with the title isapóstolos? Was it granted during their lives or at a later time?

One somewhat speculative suggestion: Constantine founded the Church of the Holy Apostles, which he intended to house relics of all the apostles, and in which he wished to be buried. He was eventually buried there, along with relics of Sts. Andrew, Luke, and Timothy. Later emperors (including Julian!) were also buried in this church. Perhaps the title was a reference to their final resting place. Constantine would certainly have intended to associate himself with the apostles by this gesture, and the title might have been a posthumous acknowledgment of the success of this use of religious symbolism.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Feb 02, 2014 4:18 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

I first thought of my seminary's "Church in History" series. Unfortunately, the author of the first volume died before he completed it, leaving a gap in the series for the period 200-450. (I know the prof who has been commissioned to fill this gap. If we can formulate a concrete question, I could ask him.) The following volume has a section on the emperor, but it does not answer your question. (It's main point is that the early Church considered the Roman Empire to be providential - not just from Constantine, but all the way back to Augustus.)

While looking at other things on the seminary bookstore's website, I came across a journal article with a promising title: The Legacy of the 13th Apostle: Origins of the East Christian Conceptions of Church and State Relation, by John A. McGuckin. The article appears in two or three places on-line and can easily be found by searching on the title. I might not have time to read the entire 38-page article for a month or so, but section 4(b), The emperor as apostle, seems to support my hypothesis about a connection between Constantine's apostolic status and his burial in the Church of the Holy Apostles. In fact, it is suggested that Constantine intended an identification with Christ himself, which was moderated to apostolic status by the Church after Constantine's death. The article also mentions his son and successor Constantius II in this section, but I'll have to read the rest of the article to understand these references.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Mr. Blue
Rigger
Posts: 1947



79887 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Feb 04, 2014 3:34 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

I'm ashamed to have you do all the digging to answer a question that is, after all, mine. However, the best I have available is the internet.

There are sites out there which will tell you that the Byzantine emperors (or some of them) were called "equal to the apostles," but I have seen none which back this up by quoting primary sources (or even secondary ones) or explain exactly which emperors or when it happened, or what it meant in context. (To be fair, Chapter 9 of one site, The Oxford History of Byzantium, put it in the context of emperors continuing, or pretending to contiune, the work of the apostles, but I don't think it really addressed the question I asked. )

So I am pretty much stuck. At this point, though, I would say it does not much matter. We know that the Byz emperors made use (sincerely or otherwise) of Christian symbolism and ideas to prop up their authority. Does it really matter if "equal to the apostles" was part of the trappings they used?

http://books.google.com/books?id=aItUoYO90UwC&pg=PA230&lpg=PA230&dq=which+byzantine+emperors+claimed+to+be+equal+to+the+apostles&source=bl&ots=VWV8OJY-co&sig=SFUr4yUkijLmIedaan_5AVIC_WI&hl=en&sa=X&ei=a1zwUu39M8nfkgentYDYBQ&ved=0CDEQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&q=ostleswhich%20byzantine%20emperors%20claimed%20to%20be%20equal%20to%20the%20apostles&f=false
_________________
" ... the mistakes that we male and female mortals make when we have our own way might fairly raise some wonder that we are so fond of it. " George Eliot
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Feb 04, 2014 5:49 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

The first few pages of the Shepard chapter in the Oxford History name many of the saints whom the Orthodox Church recognizes as "Equal to the Apostles", but he mentions the title only in connection with the Byzantine emperors, who were the sponsors or patrons of all of those saints.

Perhaps the emperors used that title the way Protestant English monarchs continued to use the title "Defender of the Faith", which had been granted to Henry VIII for his defense of the Catholic Church. They had not personally earned the title, but the rhetoric of rulership requires rulers to proclaim their legitimacy by reminding their subjects, fellow monarchs, and potential rivals of their dynastic lineage. The Defender of the Faith was the successor of Henry VIII and head of the church he founded, though it probably does not convey that message today.

It is not unreasonable to hypothesize that "Equal to the Apostles" might have originally functioned in a similar way, eventually morphing into a new meaning after 1204 or 1453.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Mr. Blue
Rigger
Posts: 1947



79887 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Feb 04, 2014 11:59 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I didn't have time to go through the Shepard chapter throughly, but it looks like he tought that Byzantine emperors at the very least wanted to look like they took their sacred role seriously - sent out missionaries, built churches, etc. So they might have seen "Equal to the Apostles" as a true description, or at least an ideal to strive for. Or might not. I suppose it depends on to what extent they believed their own propaganda?

I'm not sure what your point is with "defender of the faith." My impression is that it meant different things to different Protestant monarchs. To James I, it might mean persecuting the Brownists. To Charles I it might mean dying rather than making a compromise with Parliament. To Elizabeth II, perhaps it is just an abbreviation on a coin. Have you a particular monarch in mind?
_________________
" ... the mistakes that we male and female mortals make when we have our own way might fairly raise some wonder that we are so fond of it. " George Eliot
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Wed Feb 05, 2014 6:06 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Today we live in a world where each government asserts its rule within defined borders. Sometimes adjacent countries might disagree on where their common border lies, but no country currently claims to rule without geographic limits. (The most recent exception was probably the early communist movement, which claimed as its right and destiny to rule the whole world on behalf of the proletariat, but eventually Stalin moderated the immediate goal to "socialism in one country".)

The ancient empires accepted no such limits on their rule, in principle. Every emperor thought of himself as the ruler of the world. In areas beyond his direct rule, he considered it his right and responsibility to command or influence the local kings as much as he could. The emperors that we call "Byzantine" called themselves "Roman", and considered themselves the successors not just of Constantine, but of Augustus. Until Charlemagne, they were universally recognized as such.

Later Byzantine emperors saw the Orthodox Church, of which they were the primary patrons, as an instrument of their influence. When the Slovaks opted for Western Christianity, under Frankish influence, and when the Khazars opted for Judaism, they were consciously choosing to limit the Byzantine emperor's influence. When the Kievan Rus adopted Orthodox Christianity, they were aligning themselves with Byzantine power and prestige. (Since the Rus did not share a land border with territories under direct Byzantine rule, the alliance was relatively safe for both sides.)

This is not to question the religious sincerity of the Byzantine emperors. Some of them are recognized as saints, and some wrote hymns that are still sung every Sunday. But our modern concept of separation of church and state would have been nonsensical to an emperor. God had made him emperor of the civilized world (oikumene) to spread the light of Christian civilization, and God would defend the emperor's rule and his people as long he upheld the true faith. This was very much a continuation of the old Roman pax deorum, assimilated to the new religion.

This long-winded response should give you some context for how a Byzantine emperor might have understood himself as a successor of the apostles.


My thoughts on "Defender of the Faith" were just a consideration of the dynastic implications of perpetuating a religious title granted to one's ancestor. Here is another approach. Long-lasting monarchies tend to accumulate titles. It is easier to add new titles than to shed old ones. Giving up a title might be seen as a sign of weakness, or as making a statement of some sort, even if the title is obsolete. We saw this a few years ago when Pope Benedict XVI dropped one of his nine titles, Patriarch of the West, resulting in much controversy.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Mr. Blue
Rigger
Posts: 1947



79887 Gold -

PostPosted: Wed Feb 05, 2014 11:08 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Got a chance to read most of the Shepard chapter. It also mentioned the emperor using religion to extend his sphere of influence.

Looks to me like you are suggesting two different approaches.

1: Byzantine emperors thought of themselves as "equal to the apostles." in the context of the interaction of religion and international politics

2: Byzantine emperors simply held onto the title because getting rid of it would be more of a problem than keeping it.

Well, there were plenty of emperors, so there's no reason why they might not have kept the title for different reasons. Perhaps some of them were simply busy administrators without much time or interest for thinking through the reasons for every aspect of court ceremony.
_________________
" ... the mistakes that we male and female mortals make when we have our own way might fairly raise some wonder that we are so fond of it. " George Eliot
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Pirate's History All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group