Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

Origins of the American Revolution
Post new topic   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.     Forum Index -> Pirate's History
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Mr. Blue
Rigger
Posts: 1947



79887 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Apr 25, 2009 3:07 am    Post subject: Origins of the American Revolution Reply with quote

Origins of the American Revolution, from an ignorant and perhaps overimaginative point of view. Smile

Ok, I threatened you all with a thread on my views of the causes of the American Revolution, so let’s just hope it’s not too boring.

First of all, take this “no taxation without representation” business. The British taxed luxuries mostly, so the average American was not affected. Also, the idea of universal suffrage had not really caught on yet, so even if the Americans had been given representation in Brittan’s government, the average guy would get no vote. So while Samuel Adams and folk like him were getting steamed up about paying taxes, I don’t think the ordinary American cared. Imagine if some rich guys went around complaining that the taxes on Mercedes and yachts is too high, and the government should pay more attention to what the rich want, but not to ordinary people. Sound like effective rabble rousing to you?

So if it wasn’t taxes that drove the colonists wild, what was it? I think it was lack of trust.

Here’s some background. The revolutionaries were mostly from Scottish Presbyterian or English Puritan background. The Loyalists were largely (but not always) Anglican. During the 17th and 18th centuries, there had been seven wars in Brittan with the Anglicans on one side and the Presbyterians and/or Puritans on the other. (First Bishop’s War, Second Bishop’s War, First English Civil War, Second English Civil War, Monmouth Rebellion, The Fifteen, and The Forty-five.) Yes, I’ve simplified things quite a bit, but you get the point. The demographic groups that rebelled could look back at a history of fighting Anglican governments about religion and/or about who had a right to rule, and say (with some truth) that those governments oppressed them. Think about how groups that live nearby and have a history of fighting each other feel about each other (Tutsis and Hutus, Serbs and Croats. Okay, those are extreme examples. I am exaggerating to make a point.)

So, a number of the colonists were suspicious about the British government’s motives. The government decided to raise taxes to support troops to protect the colonies and pay for the bills racked up protecting the colonies in the past. An objective mind might say OK. But a distrustful mind might say, “Wait a minute! The French are no longer a threat to the colonies; the Indians are either allies or can be dealt with by colonial militia. Do we need British troops here to protect us, or are they really an occupying force?” Presbyterians and Puritans alike would remember that Anglican governments had persecuted them in Brittan. I don’t think that the British government had any intention of trying it again, (it wasn’t the same government anyhow) but how were the colonists to know that?

More events occurred which heightened tensions and suspicion.
1: The suppression of legitimate means of protest (when the Colonial Secretary ordered that colonial assemblies that protested the Townsend’s acts be dissolved). In effect this meant that colonists who wanted to express disagreement with the British government would have to use non-legitimate means (such as mobbing British soldiers or destruction of property.)
2: The so called Boston Massacre. Sure enough, angry citizens mobbed the solders, who grew frightened and angry and killed 5 people. Not much of a massacre, really, but it’s not the sort of thing that promotes trust either.
3: The tea tax. This takes some explanation. The British said they would tax tea, but made the tea cheaper, so it actually cost the colonists less. The plan was to bribe the colonists with cheaper tea into accepting Brittan’s right to tax them with. It didn’t work.
4: The Boston Tea Party. Sure enough, angry citizens destroyed property. It was their fault for being a bunch of hot headed vandals, but if legitimate protest is prevented, what do you expect?
5: The closure of Boston harbor.

Whether the British were justified or not in doing these things, or whether or not the colonists were justified in throwing the Boston Tea Party, is beside the point. What mattered was what people thought was going on. The British thought that they had done reasonable things and that the colonists were being unreasonable. The Americans (the ones with revolutionary tendencies, that is) thought that

A: the taxes were contrary to the British constitution,
B: and anyway the colonial assemblies had a right to say the taxes were illegal so if they thought so, and should not be suppressed for expressing an opinion
C: the occupation of Boston with troops, even though Boston was not threatened by external enemies, confirmed the suspicion that the taxes were to pay for occupying and suppressing the colonies, not for protecting them
D: the closure of Boston harbor in response to the Boston tea party showed that the British were ready to punish an entire community for the acts of a few.
E: the tax on tea was a dirty trick intended to entrap the colonists. If they once agreed that Brittan could tax them, who knows how much they might be made to pay later?
F: things are looking bad, boys. Time to stockpile some weapons just in case.

Actually, I don’t agree with all of those points, but it is easy to see how people who already suspected the government might think that way.

So the Massachusetts militia felt suspicious and stockpiled military supplies at a place called, ironically, Concord, just in case. The British got wind of it, and they were suspicious too, so they sent troops to seize the supplies, just in case.

This led to a confrontation between the British and the colonists at Lexington, which the British reached on their way to Concord. The British and American leaders both ordered that his troops should not fire unless fired upon. If orders had been obeyed, no one would have attacked. No one knows which disobedient moron fired the first shot.

There you go. A war which neither side started on purpose, caused mostly by suspicion and misunderstanding of each others’ motives.

I ventured to disagree with points that Dave made on another thread.

1: I was wrong about the oppression of Loyalists by Revolutionaries. Further research (sounds so much better than googling!) shows that Dave was correct. It was pretty bad. Both sides did things like kill enemies who had surrendered. The Revolutionaries won, so they got to commit more atrocities.

2: I still disagree with Dave on another point. He suggested (if I remember correctly) that the British did eventually offer the Americans tax free status and representation. The Revolutionary leaders did not accept the offer. I don’t argue with the facts, but I disagree with the interpretation. The American leaders were not at fault for refusing this offer. The Revolutionaries believed (wrongly) that they were facing a hostile and untrustworthy government, so naturally they would think the offer was a trap of some sort. In other words, the revolution had a momentum of its own which its so called “leaders” (like they had any real central leadership!) could not stop, and if they had tried they would have been declared traitors by their own side.
_________________
" ... the mistakes that we male and female mortals make when we have our own way might fairly raise some wonder that we are so fond of it. " George Eliot
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.     Forum Index -> Pirate's History All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group