One of the great things about this game is that there is seldom only one best way. But here is what has worked for me. If it doesn't work to salvage the game you are in, consider taking a break and checking into Rupert's fencing academy - and be patient. When I moved to swash I spent more than one game getting my butt kicked and looking up at the the guy snickering down at me from the second floor window he had just thrust me out of - or worse, looking down at the rat scurrying accross the dungeon floor - or worse yet, looking out to sea with no money or items as the months rolled by. It does get better with time.
So back to the game. Consider letting yourself get marooned again if you don't have much to lose. At least you may get a better ship and a happy crew.
Your best bet for in-game work on fencing is probably the captain of the guard. I found that I could usually get thrown out the window many times without going to prison, and could just dust myself off, select tavern, and go back for more.
As noted, there are probably several ways to win with different weapons and strategies, but the best for me was to use the parry to block an attack (you may lose half a pace, I think, but it is more forgiving on timing than trying to execute the duck or jump, especially on swash when your opponent is going too fast and gaining momentum while everything you try is coming out too late). I would follow the block with a feint, usually high chop, followed by low slash, or vice versa. At first, I would then revert to a block, rather than trying to do anything fancy to continue the attack, and repeat the feint and strike cycle. With time, you may get a sense of your opponent - and I think they vary in their alternation of attacks. For some it seems best to alternate each cycle - if you feinted high last time after the block, feint low and attack high after your next parry. For others it may work best to repeat the same cycle once or twice before shifting, or to hit the feint key two or three times quickly for emphasis before launching the real attack.
The most important element for me, though, was the block. That seemed to be the key to breaking the acceleration of the opponents attack, which otherwise moves quickly to that feeling of helplessness where whatever you try to do is just too slow. With the block, I could set up a feinting attack. Now, with the fencing skill, I can generally continue to win most of the time even at maximum age on swash - though it is definintely worthwhile to get all the gear you can.
There are still things I am learning, that may work great for others - like the taunt, or using a cutlass instead of the rapier - so I don't mean to discount anyone else's method. But you might give this a try. Good luck. |