I'm not all that comfortable with fencing, and this is a good thing, because if you get the point, you're perforated!
Your crew's mood is everything in fencing. Keeping them happy is a must if you don't want to be skewered by a lesser opponent. Having greater numbers in crew helps just a tad, but don't let this fool you if the boys are unhappy. They'll be dropping like flies while some Dutch merchant slices and dices you. I've taken vessels with three times my strength by fencing when I'm young, but the crew was ecstatic and enjoyed themselves as they threw their opponents over the sides.
IN THE FIGHT: I have a penchant for leaning on my four-button. That is the thrust attack. You can get it off faster than a slash or lash attack. To slash (overhead swing, the opponent rears back to his left then swings high on you) or to lash (opponent rears back to his right and swings low on you) it takes a moment to set up the attack. The rearing back leaves an opening for a good quick thrust, the four-button. So, it's best to attack when you're being attacked by this means. You can get your thrust in faster than he can set up his slash or lash. If you thrust on his thrust, it's usually even, unless you're at an advantage and can sometimes get yours in before he does his. If you thrust as he defends against the other two, your blow will land invariably. So, on a percentage basis, leaning on that four button avails more.
Naturally, there are exceptions to this. Sometimes, about every third or fourth shot, your opponent parries. This is the defense to a thrust. If you're using a lighter sword than he, your thrust ricohets off into the air, and it takes you a moment to regain control of it, by then it doesn't matter what button you push, he'll land his best shot on you. This can best be compensated for by using a sword equal to, or heavier than his. Longswords are generally best for this approach to fencing. If your opponent uses one, you'll regain control quickly enough to respond to him, and it falls equally. If he's using a cutlass, you can still regain control quickly enough to react to his offensive move. If you're using a rapier against either of these two, you'll get hit.
He parries when he's holding his sword perpendicular to himself, about waist high with the blade toward you. This isn't an offensive move, so you really don't have to react to it at all. If you go for a slash, or lash, he'll have enough time to thrust on you from the parry, so it's a bit of a sticky spot, sword weight helps a lot here. You can parry as he does, then continue to thrust. But, sometimes he continues to parry. If your blade is equal to his, just keep thrusting into it. He'll give way to something else, and you'll resume landing blows.
IF HE PARRIES against your thrust and you are leaning on your button, you won't be set up quickly enough to act on his next move. The program seems to stack commands and execuate them in order, so if you've pounded that button several times, it'll follow your directions and you have to wait out the string. This isn't absolute, but close enough to be a problem. When he parries your thrust, take your finger off the button, there'll be a short instant when you regain control, and he moves to another maneuver, you can then get in another stab.
I've tried using the other moves, but it seems to leave me in as vulnerable a position against his thrust, as he is against mine. SO, I live by that four button. Just don't load up on it like it's a machine gun. Use it like it's a single shot. Press - release, and odds-on you'll land more shots than he. When you find this not working very well, take a look at your own status, you'll find you're getting kind of old.
With the "upgrades", silk shirt, vest, cuirass and well-balanced swords, you can defeat anyone BUT Montebaln. I've knocked him off his ship this way, early-on, but have had to reduce his crew to only one member before boarding his ship after I age up to about 34 yrs old.
That other guy with the maps to my relatives, he's no more difficult than a captain of the guard when he's in the tavern. He's not better than you on a ship, but your crew must be in a really good mood and you should be better manned before fencing him.
MONTEBALN's hideout - when you find it, and you win to his gates, you're going to have to fence him to win those points. This is probably the most difficult part of the game, and I've only succeeded in getting this far, not winning the fight. It's so late in the game, I've dropped fencing as a major offense anyway, and he's way better than me by this late in the game. This confrontation must be a major strategic goal in the game, and this method of fencing probably won't avail much. It's been said one can practice the other fencing moves, defensive/slash/lash, on captains of the guard, but I've been too busy doing other things in the game to bother with this. I do have it in mind to try it, however...so be advised Montebaln is out there and you'll have to fight him eventually. I imagine a well-rounded use of ALL the buttons will come in more than handy when (and if) that time comes.
Argh!
Airsaw |